The Absolute Best Seafood in Bainbridge Island [Updated 2024]

Having reviewed 12 outstanding seafood establishments on Bainbridge Island, I am confident that my expertise will lead you to the most remarkable dining experiences. Located just a ferry ride away from Seattle, Bainbridge Island boasts a vibrant culinary scene, particularly when it comes to fresh, delectable seafood options.

Whether you are in search of succulent crab legs, mouthwatering salmon, or perfectly cooked oysters, I have meticulously compiled a comprehensive list of the top-notch seafood spots that will leave you craving for more. Prepare to embark on an unforgettable seafood journey as we delve into the best that Bainbridge Island has to offer.

Let's dive in!

The Islander

Highlights
Friendly servers
Variety of drinks
Signature burger
Quaint atmosphere

As I stepped into The Islander, I was immediately greeted by the warm and friendly servers, who went above and beyond to make me feel welcome. The atmosphere was quaint, with rustic decor and a cozy, inviting ambiance that made me feel right at home.

When it came to the seafood, The Islander did not disappoint. While they are known for their excellent seafood options, I decided to venture off the beaten path and try their signature burger. And let me tell you, it was a decision I didn't regret. The juicy patty was cooked to perfection, topped with a tantalizing blend of flavors that left me craving more with each bite.

For those looking for a seafood experience, The Islander offers a variety of options that cater to every palate. From fresh, succulent oysters to mouthwatering salmon dishes, their seafood selection was cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor.

To complement my meal, I indulged in a variety of drinks from their extensive menu. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cocktail or a craft beer, The Islander has you covered. Their bartenders were knowledgeable and provided excellent recommendations to enhance my dining experience.

Overall, my visit to The Islander was nothing short of exceptional. The combination of friendly servers, a wide variety of drinks, a delectable signature burger, and an inviting atmosphere made this a standout experience. So, seafood lover or not, make sure to add The Islander to your list of must-visit restaurants on Bainbridge Island.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Sanibel Island.

Harbour Public House

Highlights
Perfect memories
Fresh seafood
Beautiful views
Friendly staff
Casual waterfront

From the moment I arrived at Harbour Public House, I knew I was in for a treat. The waterfront location provided beautiful views of the sparkling waters, which set the perfect backdrop for a seafood feast. As I entered the restaurant, the friendly staff greeted me with warm smiles and made me feel right at home.

The highlight of my experience at Harbour Public House was the fresh seafood. Every bite was a burst of flavors and textures that delighted my taste buds. The variety of options on the menu ensured there was something for every seafood lover, from perfectly grilled salmon to succulent crab cakes.

The casual waterfront ambiance of the restaurant made it the ideal place to create perfect memories. Whether I was enjoying a delicious meal with friends or taking in the stunning sunset with a loved one, Harbour Public House provided the ultimate dining experience.

What truly sets Harbour Public House apart is their commitment to quality. The seafood was sourced locally, ensuring that each dish was as fresh as possible. The attention to detail was evident in every aspect of my dining experience.

If you find yourself in Bainbridge Island and craving seafood, I highly recommend Harbour Public House. Its combination of fresh seafood, beautiful views, and friendly staff create an unbeatable dining destination. So go ahead, indulge in the flavors of the sea at Harbour Public House and prepare to be delighted.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Hawaii Big Island.

Agate Restaurant

Highlights
Awesome service
Tasty cocktails
Delicious entrées
Smiling waitress
Flavorful crab cakes

From the moment I stepped into Agate Restaurant, I was greeted with a warm smile from the waitress, which instantly set a positive tone for my dining experience. I can confidently say their service is nothing short of awesome.

As I settled into my seat, I couldn't help but notice the extensive cocktail menu. Intrigued, I decided to try one of their signature concoctions. The blend of flavors in my drink was simply delightful, and I could tell that Agate Restaurant takes great care in crafting tasty cocktails that complement their seafood options.

Speaking of seafood, let's talk about the delicious entrées. As a seafood enthusiast, I had high expectations. Agate Restaurant did not disappoint. Their menu offers a wide variety of seafood options, and I opted for the flavorful crab cakes. Each bite was a heavenly explosion of fresh crab meat and perfectly balanced seasonings. It was evident that the chefs at Agate Restaurant take great pride in their culinary creations.

What truly sets Agate Restaurant apart is their attention to detail and commitment to providing a memorable dining experience. The waitress was knowledgeable about the menu, accommodating to special dietary requests, and always wearing a warm smile. It's these small but significant touches that make Agate Restaurant stand out in Bainbridge Island's seafood scene.

In conclusion, Agate Restaurant is a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts seeking a blend of exceptional service, spectacular cocktails, and delectable seafood entrées, particularly their mouthwatering crab cakes. Your taste buds and dining experience will certainly be grateful.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Staten Island.

Proper Fish

I had the pleasure of dining at Proper Fish in charming Bainbridge Island, and let me tell you, it was quite the catch! The playful atmosphere was infused with a professional touch, and the seafood was simply outstanding. From the succulent fish and chips to the mouthwatering lobster rolls, Proper Fish knows how to reel in seafood lovers with their fresh and flavorful dishes. It's the perfect place to satisfy your seafood cravings while enjoying the island's scenic beauty.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Tybee Island.

Ba Sa Restaurant

short, 50-word summary review: Blissful at Ba Sa! Their seafood selection is top-notch, with flavors that dance on your palate. From the succulent lobster to the delicate scallops, every dish is a journey of culinary delight. What a gem in Bainbridge Island for seafood lovers!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Catalina Island.

Café Hitchcock

Café Hitchcock in Bainbridge Island left me hooked on their delectable seafood offerings! From their succulent wild-caught salmon to their perfectly seasoned Dungeness crab cakes, every bite was a flavor explosion. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere added to the already outstanding dining experience. I cannot wait to return and indulge in more mouthwatering seafood delights!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Fenwick Island.

The Plate & Pint

The Plate & Pint in Bainbridge Island offers a delightful seafood experience that makes your taste buds dance with joy. From the succulent salmon to the tender oysters, their menu is a seafood lover's dream. The fresh and flavorful dishes, paired with attentive service, create an unforgettable dining experience. Don't miss out on this hidden gem on the island!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in South Padre Island.

Streamliner Diner

In my quest for the best seafood in Bainbridge Island, I stumbled upon the charming Streamliner Diner. This funky joint oozes retro vibes and serves up a delicious selection of seafood dishes. The succulent crab cakes were a standout, with their perfect balance of flavors. A must-visit for seafood enthusiasts!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Anna Maria Island.

San Carlos Restaurant

San Carlos Restaurant in Bainbridge Island is a delightful seafood spot that promises a playful yet professional experience. From the moment I stepped in, I was captivated by the vibrant atmosphere and the enticing aroma of fresh seafood. The flavorful dishes exceeded my expectations, leaving me craving for more. San Carlos Restaurant is undoubtedly a top contender in the search for the best seafood in Bainbridge Island.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Cambridge MA.

Casa Rojas

Casa Rojas in Bainbridge Island is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. Their menu is filled with a variety of fresh catches, cooked to perfection. From succulent shrimp to flavorful salmon, every bite is a delightful experience. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a seafood feast. Don't miss out on their signature seafood paella—it's a culinary masterpiece! Whether you're a seafood aficionado or just looking to indulge, Casa Rojas is a must-visit seafood haven!

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Rhode Island.

Doc's Marina Grill

Doc's Marina Grill in Bainbridge Island is a true seafood heaven! Their menu offers a delightful variety of fresh and flavorful seafood dishes. From succulent Dungeness crab to crispy fish and chips, their options are a pure delight. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make Doc's a perfect spot for seafood enthusiasts. Don't miss it!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Marco Island.

Seabird

Seabird in Bainbridge Island is a hidden gem that knows how to satisfy seafood lovers. Their fresh and flavorful dishes are a delight for the senses. The crispy fried calamari and the succulent grilled salmon are culinary masterpieces. With its lush coastal ambiance and excellent service, Seabird is a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Evansville Indiana.