The Absolute Best Seafood in Cape May NJ [Updated 2024]

With a total of 12 exceptional seafood establishments reviewed, I have meticulously explored every nook and cranny of Cape May, NJ, in search of the finest culinary treasures the coast has to offer. From pristine oceanic flavors to unparalleled seafood dining experiences, this guide aims to unveil the absolute best the region has in store for seafood enthusiasts.

Each review has been thoughtfully crafted to highlight the hidden gems, impeccable freshness, and delectable flavors that make these establishments stand out. Get ready to embark on a gastronomic adventure as we navigate through the crème de la crème of Cape May's seafood scene.

Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar

Highlights
Excellent food
Fresh seafood
Accommodating to dietary needs
Friendly and helpful staff
Great service

Let me start by saying, the food at Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar is simply excellent! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm smile and a cozy atmosphere that set the stage for an unforgettable seafood dining experience.

The menu boasted an array of options, but what truly impressed me was the quality of the seafood. Every bite was bursting with freshness, as if they had just plucked the fish straight from the ocean. The flavors were infused with a delicate balance of spices and seasonings, enhancing the natural taste of the seafood.

One of the aspects that particularly caught my attention was how accommodating the restaurant was to dietary needs. As someone who follows a specific diet, the staff went out of their way to ensure my needs were met without compromising on taste or quality. I appreciated their willingness to cater to my preferences.

Speaking of the staff, they were not only friendly but genuinely helpful as well. They were more than happy to answer any questions I had about the menu and provided suggestions based on their personal favorites. Their knowledge and passion for seafood was evident, adding to the overall enjoyment of the dining experience.

The service at Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar was top-notch. The staff were attentive and efficient, ensuring that my needs were met with every interaction. From the moment I ordered to the moment I left, I felt well taken care of.

Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar is a gem in Cape May NJ that truly deserves recognition for its outstanding seafood. With excellent food, fresh seafood, accommodating service for dietary needs, a friendly staff, and great service, it’s no wonder why this establishment has become a go-to spot for seafood enthusiasts like me. Don't miss the opportunity to indulge in the finest seafood offerings that Cape May has to offer at Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Cape May NJ.

Hemingway's Steaks & Seafood Restaurant

Highlights
Unbelievable Oysters
Lump Crab Cake
Excellent Service
Warm Ambiance
Divine Crème Brûlée

Let me start by saying that the oysters at Hemingway's Steaks & Seafood are unbelievable. They were plump, juicy, and bursting with flavor. Each bite transported me to the seaside, with the briny, fresh taste leaving me craving for more. It's safe to say that Hemingway's knows their seafood, and they know it well.

Aside from the oysters, I also tried their famous lump crab cake, and it was a true treat for my taste buds. The crab cake was unlike any other I've had before - perfectly seasoned, with generous chunks of succulent crab meat. It was an absolute delight to devour and left me wishing I had ordered two.

What truly sets Hemingway's apart, however, is their excellent service. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warmth and hospitality. The waitstaff was incredibly attentive and knowledgeable, providing recommendations and answering any questions I had. Their dedication to ensuring a remarkable dining experience truly shone through.

The restaurant itself had a warm ambiance, with dim lighting and cozy seating arrangements. It felt like stepping into an intimate coastal retreat, making it the perfect setting to enjoy a delicious seafood feast.

To end my meal on a sweet note, I indulged in their divine crème brûlée. The crackling caramelized sugar atop the silky, creamy custard created a delightful contrast of textures, leaving me completely satisfied.

In conclusion, my visit to Hemingway's Steaks & Seafood Restaurant was an absolute delight. From the unbelievable oysters and lump crab cake to the excellent service and warm ambiance, every aspect of my dining experience was top-notch. If you're on the hunt for the best seafood in Cape May NJ, Hemingway's is a must-visit.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Wildwood.

SeaSalt Restaurant

Highlights
Best meal in Cape
Incredible chef
Breathtaking view
Perfect desserts
Artistic presentation

As soon as I stepped into SeaSalt, I knew I was in for a treat. The intimate and modern ambiance combined with the breathtaking view of the ocean set the stage for what turned out to be the best meal in Cape May.

The chef at SeaSalt is undoubtedly an incredible culinary artist. Every dish that graced my table was a work of art, from the delicate arrangement of vibrant colors to the precise placement of each component. It was a feast for the eyes before it even touched my lips.

Now, let's talk about the seafood. Oh, the seafood! It was clear that only the freshest ingredients were used. My taste buds danced with delight as I savored each bite of the succulent fare that was expertly prepared. From the tender lobster and crab to the perfectly grilled marinated scallops, each dish delivered a burst of flavors that transported me to the sea.

And let's not forget about the desserts. SeaSalt knows how to end a meal on a high note. The desserts were perfect, providing just the right amount of sweetness to satisfy any craving.

What truly impressed me about SeaSalt was the artistic presentation of each dish. The attention to detail was evident in every aspect, from the way the sauce was drizzled to the final garnish that adorned the masterpiece. It was clear that the chef poured their heart and soul into each creation.

SeaSalt Restaurant in Cape May NJ is truly a hidden gem. With its incredible chef, breathtaking view, and perfect desserts, it offers an unparalleled dining experience. Whether you're a seafood enthusiast or simply looking for an extraordinary culinary adventure, I highly recommend putting SeaSalt on your must-try list.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Avalon NJ.

The Pier House

After devouring the most delicious seafood dishes at The Pier House in Cape May NJ, I can confidently say that it deserves a spot among the best in town. From the succulent lobster to the perfectly grilled fish, every bite was a taste of ocean bliss. Don't forget to order their signature crab cakes, they're to die for! The vibrant and cozy ambiance added an extra oomph to the dining experience. For seafood lovers seeking perfection on a plate, The Pier House is an absolute must-visit in Cape May NJ.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Lewes Delaware.

The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar

The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar in Cape May NJ is a seafood haven! With a playful yet professional atmosphere, I was impressed by their diverse seafood offerings. From perfectly seared scallops to succulent lobster rolls, their fresh and flavorful dishes won me over. It's a must-visit spot for seafood lovers in Cape May!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rehoboth Beach.

Ocean 7

Ocean 7 in Cape May NJ is a delightful hub for seafood lovers. From the succulent shrimp to the tantalizing lobster rolls, every bite is like a party in your mouth. The friendly staff adds to the lively atmosphere, making it a top contender for the best seafood spot in town.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Rehoboth Beach.

Iccara Italian Bistro

Iccara Italian Bistro in Cape May NJ is a hidden gem that will make your taste buds sing with joy. Their seafood offerings are truly divine. From the succulent scallops to the buttery lobster, every bite is like a taste of the ocean. Don't miss out on their mouthwatering seafood creations!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rehoboth.

The Lobster House

The Lobster House in Cape May NJ is a haven for seafood lovers! From the moment you step in, you're greeted by the crisp scent of the ocean and the inviting bustle of a vibrant seafood market. The menu is as diverse as it is delicious, offering everything from buttery lobster rolls to flaky broiled scallops. You'll want to save room for the indulgent crab cakes, which are the showstopper of the night. The casual yet bustling atmosphere makes it the perfect place to enjoy a feast with friends and family. Honestly, if you're in Cape May NJ, you simply can't miss The Lobster House!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Dewey Beach.

Lucky Bones Back Water Grille

Lucky Bones Back Water Grille in Cape May NJ is a seafood lover's dream come true. The ambiance is laid back and inviting, perfect for a coastal dining experience. The menu boasts an impressive array of fresh seafood, from succulent lobster to mouthwatering scallops. The service was top-notch, ensuring a delightful evening. Don't miss this gem when searching for the best seafood in Cape May NJ!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Bethany Beach.

Cape May Fish Market

At Cape May Fish Market in Cape May NJ, I found a seafood-lover's paradise. The ambiance was delightfully lively, promoting a playful yet professional atmosphere. The menu featured a wide array of fresh, flavorful seafood options that were a feast for the senses. From the succulent lobster tails to the mouthwatering crab cakes, every bite was a taste of pure oceanic bliss. The attentive and knowledgeable staff made sure that each dish was cooked to perfection. If you're in Cape May, Cape May Fish Market is a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Fenwick Island.

Fins Bar & Grille

At Fins Bar & Grille in Cape May NJ, I had a fin-tastic seafood adventure! From their mouthwatering crab cakes to their fresh and succulent lobster rolls, every bite was a party in my mouth. The friendly staff and lively atmosphere made it a night to remember. A must-visit for seafood lovers!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Dover DE.

Harbor View Restaurant

Harbor View Restaurant in Cape May NJ is a true jewel on the shore. From the moment I stepped inside, the charming maritime decor transported me to a coastal paradise. Their seafood menu is extensive and sophisticated, with options ranging from classic fish and chips to creative lobster creations. The flavor of their dishes is impeccable, perfectly showcasing the freshness of the seafood. And the harbor view from their outdoor seating area? Simply breathtaking. If you're looking for the best seafood in Cape May, this is the place to be.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Ocean City MD.