The Absolute Best Seafood in City Island New York [Updated 2024]

Having personally sampled and reviewed 12 seafood establishments in City Island, New York, I am excited to share my expertise with you. Having an intimate knowledge of the local seafood scene, I have pinpointed the absolute best restaurants that offer a delightful array of delectable seafood dishes.

Whether you're a fan of succulent lobster, fresh oysters, or mouthwatering fish and chips, this comprehensive guide will ensure you make the most informed dining choices. From upscale seafood eateries with breathtaking waterfront views to hidden gems that offer the freshest catches, get ready to embark on a seafood journey like no other in City Island, New York.

The Original Crab Shanty

Highlights
Affordable lunch specials
Outstanding customer service
Variety of seafood options
Great strong drinks
Big, thick crab legs

Walking into The Original Crab Shanty, I was immediately drawn in by the lively and playful atmosphere. The staff greeted me with a warm welcome, and I knew I was in for a memorable experience.

One of the first things that caught my attention was their affordable lunch specials. As someone who appreciates quality seafood without breaking the bank, this was a delightful surprise. The selection was impressive, ranging from mouthwatering crab cakes to tender lobster rolls.

But what truly set The Original Crab Shanty apart was their outstanding customer service. The staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and eager to cater to my every need. They made me feel like a valued guest, which enhanced my dining experience even more.

The menu boasted a diverse variety of seafood options, from classic dishes to creative innovations. Each dish was expertly prepared, showcasing the freshness and quality of the ingredients.

Now, let's talk about the drinks. Oh boy, were they strong and delicious! Whether you prefer a classic margarita or a refreshing mojito, The Original Crab Shanty knows how to craft a cocktail that will leave you wanting more.

But the true highlight for me was their big, thick crab legs. Bursting with flavor and cooked to perfection, they were a seafood lover's dream come true. I couldn't resist cracking open the shells and savoring every succulent bite.

Overall, my visit to The Original Crab Shanty was a playful and professional culinary adventure. With their affordable lunch specials, outstanding customer service, variety of seafood options, great strong drinks, and big, thick crab legs, this restaurant undeniably deserves a spot on the list of the best seafood in City Island New York.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Manhattan New York.

Artie's Steak and Seafood Restaurant

Highlights
Exceptional service
Juicy and tasty NY Strip
Buttery lobster
Fresh seafood
Amazing Zuppa

Walking into Artie's, I was immediately captivated by the warm and inviting atmosphere. The exceptional service from the friendly staff further enhanced the dining experience.

When it came to choosing my main course, I couldn't resist the allure of their signature NY Strip. The moment the plate arrived at my table, I could see why it is so highly regarded. The steak was cooked to perfection, tender and juicy with every bite bursting with flavor.

Being a seafood enthusiast, I couldn't pass up the opportunity to indulge in their buttery lobster. The lobster was cooked to perfection, with the flesh clinging to the shell and effortlessly slipping out with each crack. It was a culinary delight, melting in my mouth with a rich, buttery finish.

Artie's commitment to sourcing the freshest seafood was evident in every dish. The seafood was of the highest quality and flawlessly prepared, leaving me craving more with every bite.

One dish that stood out was their amazing Zuppa. The flavors were a symphony in my mouth, a harmonious blend of fresh seafood, aromatic herbs, and a tantalizing broth that warmed my soul.

Overall, my experience at Artie's Steak and Seafood Restaurant was exceptional. From the top-notch service to the mouthwatering dishes, this restaurant truly showcases the best seafood that City Island New York has to offer. If you're in search of a memorable seafood experience, make sure to visit Artie's, where flavor and hospitality meld together in perfect harmony.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Brooklyn New York.

City Island Lobster House

Highlights
Enormous crab/lobster plate
Fabulous waiter
Magnificent experience
Outdoor dining with marina view
Delicious food and great service

Let me start by saying that the crab and lobster plate at City Island Lobster House is absolutely enormous. If you're a seafood lover like me, you'll be in heaven with the amount of fresh, succulent seafood they serve on that plate. It's a feast fit for a seafood connoisseur!

The service at this establishment is top-notch. Our waiter was not only knowledgeable about the menu but also had a fabulous personality that made the whole dining experience even more enjoyable. His recommendations were spot-on, ensuring that we had a magnificent experience from start to finish.

One standout feature of City Island Lobster House is their outdoor dining area, which offers a stunning view of the marina. Sitting there, savoring the delicious seafood, and watching the boats go by truly adds to the whole ambiance.

Speaking of the food, let me tell you, it is delicious. Each dish we tried was prepared with care and bursting with flavor. From the perfectly cooked lobster to the tender crab meat, every bite left us wanting more. And the service, wow! The waitstaff was attentive, ensuring that we had everything we needed without being intrusive.

All in all, City Island Lobster House is a gem when it comes to seafood in City Island New York. The combination of their enormous crab and lobster plate, fabulous waiter, and magnificent dining experience in the outdoor area with a marina view creates an unforgettable seafood adventure. If you're looking for fantastic seafood and great service, make sure to visit City Island Lobster House.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Atlantic City New Jersey.

Sea Shore Restaurant

Sea Shore Restaurant in City Island New York serves up some of the freshest and most flavorful seafood in town. From the succulent lobster rolls to the buttery crab cakes, every bite is an oceanic delight. With its laid-back ambiance and friendly staff, Sea Shore is surely a seafood lover's paradise.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Boston.

Sammy's Shrimp Box

Sammy's Shrimp Box in City Island New York is a hidden gem. Their freshly caught seafood is prepared with care and the flavors are out of this world. The crispy batter on the shrimp had me hooked, while the succulent lobster tail was a true delight. The friendly staff and charming waterfront view make for a memorable dining experience.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Baltimore.

Tony's Pier

Tony's Pier, the hidden gem of City Island, boasts an extraordinary seafood experience. From the succulent lobster rolls to the mouthwatering clam chowder, every bite is a burst of oceanic delight. The lively atmosphere and friendly staff make Tony's Pier a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Ocean City MD.

Sammy's Fish Box

At Sammy's Fish Box in City Island New York, my taste buds embarked on a seafood adventure like no other. From succulent crab legs to buttery lobster tails, every bite was a burst of coastal bliss. The playful yet professional atmosphere added to the overall enjoyment. A must-visit for seafood enthusiasts!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Portsmouth NH.

The Black Whale

The Black Whale in City Island New York is a must-visit destination for seafood lovers. The menu is a delightful fusion of flavors, featuring fresh catches from the sea. From the flaky fish to the succulent shellfish, every bite is a seafood lover's dream. The charming ambiance and friendly staff add to the overall enjoyment.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rehoboth Beach.

Seafood City

Seafood City in City Island New York is a seafood lover's paradise! From the moment I walked in, the enticing aroma of fresh seafood filled the air. The vibrant and lively atmosphere perfectly complemented the mouthwatering dishes. The menu featured a wide array of delectable options, ranging from classic New England clam chowder to succulent lobster rolls. The attention to detail in presentation and flawless execution in flavors truly made this dining experience memorable. Whether you're a seafood aficionado or a curious foodie, Seafood City is a must-visit destination in City Island New York.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Gloucester MA.

Seafood Kingz 2 Inc

Seafood Kingz 2 Inc in City Island New York is a hidden gem that deserves a spot in the article about the best seafood in the area. Their fresh and flavor-packed menu offers a playful twist on classic seafood dishes. The vibrant and welcoming atmosphere makes it a must-visit spot for seafood lovers.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Ocean City MD.

JP's

JP's in City Island New York is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. Their dishes are mouthwatering and bursting with flavor. From their delectable lobster rolls to their succulent grilled fish, JP's knows how to wow your taste buds. A must-visit for any seafood aficionado in the Big Apple.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in New England.

Vistamar

Vistamar in City Island New York is a hidden gem when it comes to seafood. Their menu boasts a tantalizing array of fresh catches, from succulent shrimp to melt-in-your-mouth lobster. But what sets Vistamar apart is the unbeatable waterfront view that accompanies each dish. The combination of delicious food and breathtaking scenery make this spot a must-visit for seafood lovers in City Island New York.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rochester NY.