The Absolute Best Seafood in Door County [Updated 2024]

Introduction: As an expert with years of experience indulging in various seafood delicacies, I am thrilled to present to you the ultimate guide to the best seafood in Door County! Having reviewed a staggering 12 seafood establishments dotted throughout this picturesque Wisconsin peninsula, I have carefully handpicked the premier dining destinations that will tantalize your taste buds and leave you craving more. Whether you seek succulent shrimp, melt-in-your-mouth salmon, or delectable crab, this comprehensive guide aims to steer you towards the most exceptional seafood experiences Door County has to offer. Prepare to embark on a mouthwatering journey through the region's finest seafood establishments, exploring flavors that are sure to seduce even the most discerning palate.

Barringer's Restaurant

Highlights
Beautiful seating
Fantastic lobster roll
Amazing fries
Knowledgeable staff
Perfectly cooked steaks

Upon entering Barringer's Restaurant, I was immediately struck by the beautiful seating. The cozy ambiance and tasteful decor created a welcoming atmosphere that made me excited to start my culinary journey.

Of course, my main focus was on the seafood, and I must say that Barringer's did not disappoint. The lobster roll was absolutely fantastic. The generous portion of tender, succulent lobster meat was perfectly complemented by a light and creamy dressing. Each bite was a delightful explosion of flavors that left me wanting more.

And let's not forget about the amazing fries. Crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and perfectly seasoned, they were the ideal sidekick to the lobster roll.

What impressed me the most, however, was the knowledgeable staff. They were eager to answer any questions I had about the menu and made excellent recommendations. Their expertise added an extra layer of enjoyment to my dining experience.

While Barringer's is primarily known for their seafood, I couldn't help but venture outside of my usual comfort zone and try one of their perfectly cooked steaks. It was like biting into a piece of culinary heaven. The meat was tender, flavorful, and cooked to perfection, leaving me with a satisfied smile on my face.

In conclusion, Barringer's Restaurant in Door County is a seafood lover's paradise. From the beautiful seating to the incredible lobster roll and amazing fries, everything about this place screams excellence. With a knowledgeable staff and perfectly cooked steaks, Barringer's exceeds expectations and sets the bar high for the best seafood experience in Door County.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Gwinnett County.

The English Inn

Highlights
Cool ambiance
Outstanding service
Delicious food
Generous portions
Amazing drinks

Walking into The English Inn, I was immediately captivated by the cool ambiance: dimly lit with soft music playing in the background, creating an atmosphere that transported me to a charming British pub. The friendly staff greeted me with warmth and provided outstanding service throughout my entire visit, making me feel like a valued guest.

Let's talk about the star of the show: the seafood. My taste buds were in for a treat as I indulged in the delicious food that The English Inn had to offer. From the moment the seafood platter arrived at my table, I knew I was in for a culinary delight. The freshness of the seafood, combined with their expert preparation, made each bite a delectable experience. The crab cakes were moist and flavorful, the shrimp were perfectly cooked and tender, and the scallops melted in my mouth.

Not only was the quality outstanding, but the portions were impressively generous. The English Inn knows how to satisfy seafood lovers' appetites. Each dish was served with a variety of side dishes that perfectly complemented the main course.

To wash down the fantastic seafood feast, I indulged in their amazing drinks. Whether it was a perfectly crafted cocktail or a glass of wine from their thoughtful selection, the drinks added an extra layer of enjoyment to the experience.

Overall, my visit to The English Inn was a delightful journey for my taste buds. The combination of cool ambiance, outstanding service, delicious food, generous portions, and amazing drinks make it a must-visit destination for seafood enthusiasts in Door County.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Fairfield County.

Hill Street

Highlights
Unique menu options
Delicious spin on food
Excellent food and service
Comfortable atmosphere
Fresh and flavorful food

Let me just start by saying that Hill Street offers a refreshing twist on seafood dishes that you won't find anywhere else in Door County. The unique menu options got my taste buds excited from the get-go.

From the moment I walked into the restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The comfortable atmosphere instantly made me feel relaxed and ready to indulge in some seafood goodness.

As I perused the menu, I couldn't help but notice the delicious spin they put on traditional seafood dishes. The combination of flavors and presentation was truly impressive. Each bite was a delightful surprise that kept me coming back for more.

Not only was the food exceptional, but the service was top-notch as well. The staff was knowledgeable and attentive, ensuring that my dining experience was nothing short of perfection.

But let's not forget the star of the show – the seafood itself. Hill Street prides itself on sourcing the freshest ingredients, and boy, does it show. The seafood was fresh and flavorful, bursting with the essence of the sea.

In conclusion, Hill Street is a hidden gem in Door County when it comes to seafood. The excellent food and service, combined with the unique menu options and comfortable atmosphere, make it a must-try for seafood lovers. So, if you're looking for a dining experience that will leave you wanting more, head on over to Hill Street and prepare to be dazzled!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Pinellas County.

The Log Den

I had the pleasure of indulging in the seafood offerings at The Log Den in Door County, and let me tell you, it was a treasure trove of deliciousness. From the succulent lobster tail to the perfectly seared scallops, every dish was a masterpiece. Trust me when I say, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Broward County.

White Gull Inn

White Gull Inn in Door County is an exquisite seafood destination that tickles your taste buds with their fresh and succulent offerings. Their attention to detail in preparing seafood dishes is truly commendable. From perfectly grilled salmon to flaky and tender whitefish, every bite is a seafood lover's dream come true. The top-notch service and cozy ambiance add an extra layer of enjoyment to your dining experience. Don't miss the chance to indulge in the best seafood that Door County has to offer at White Gull Inn.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Monmouth County.

Nightingale Supper Club

Nightingale Supper Club in Door County is a delightful treasure for seafood enthusiasts. From the moment I walked in, the playful yet professional atmosphere set the tone for a memorable meal. Their fresh catch of the day was exquisitely prepared, with flavors that danced upon my palate. The knowledgeable staff provided superb service, making it a truly exceptional dining experience. Seafood lovers, this spot is worth every succulent bite.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Brevard County.

Pelletier's Restaurant & Fish Boil

Pelletier's Restaurant & Fish Boil in Door County deserves a place on the list of the best seafood spots. They deliver an exceptional culinary experience, boasting a playful yet professional atmosphere. The fish boil is a must-try - the perfectly cooked fish literally melts in your mouth.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Baltimore County.

Kettle Black Fish Boil

Oh la la! Kettle Black Fish Boil in Door County is a seafood extravaganza! Their playful yet professional staff knows how to create a memorable dining experience. Bold flavors, fresh catches, and a delightful ambiance make this a must-try for any seafood lover in Door County.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Marin County.

Alexander's of Door County

Alexander's of Door County in Door County is a seafood lover's paradise. From succulent shrimp to perfectly grilled salmon, their menu is a treasure trove of oceanic delights. The playful yet professional ambiance adds an extra touch of magic to your seafood feast. A must-visit for any seafood enthusiast in Door County.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Cobb County.

Harbor Fish Market & Grille

"Prepare to have your taste buds sail away at Harbor Fish Market & Grille in Door County! From the moment I stepped inside, I was hooked on their fresh and flavorful seafood dishes. The catch of the day was a succulent delight, perfectly cooked and expertly paired with delicate spices. The seafood platter was a treasure trove of various ocean delights, bursting with flavors that transported me straight to the coast. The attentive and friendly staff provided top-notch service, making me feel like seafood royalty. Don't scale back on your visit to Door County without a stop at Harbor Fish Market & Grille!"

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Bucks County.

Boathouse On The Bay

Oh, boy! Boathouse On The Bay in Door County is a seafood lover's paradise. Their fresh and succulent seafood offerings will make your taste buds dance with delight. From crispy calamari to buttery lobster tails, every bite is a heavenly experience. Don't miss their impressive oyster bar for some shucking good fun. Go ahead, dive in and savor the flavors of the sea at Boathouse On The Bay.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Bergen County.

BaySide Tavern

Let me tell you, folks, BaySide Tavern is a hidden seafood gem in Door County. From the moment I stepped into this lively joint, I knew I was in for a treat. The menu is a tantalizing voyage through the sea, with options like indulgent lobster rolls and perfectly grilled salmon. The freshness of the seafood is unmatched, and the creative, flavorful dishes are a testament to the skills of the talented chefs. Don't forget to pair your meal with one of their signature cocktails for the ultimate dining experience. With its playful yet professional atmosphere, BaySide Tavern is a must-visit for seafood lovers in Door County.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Orange County.