The Absolute Best Seafood in Fort Myers Beach [Updated 2024]

Having reviewed a total of 12 seafood restaurants in Fort Myers Beach, I can confidently say that I have uncovered the true gems for seafood lovers. With my discerning palate and passion for all things seafood, I have meticulously sampled an array of dishes, scouring the bustling streets and tranquil waterfronts for the finest culinary experiences.

Fort Myers Beach is renowned for its fresh seafood offerings, but knowing where to find the best can be a daunting task. That's why I have taken it upon myself to compile this comprehensive list, ensuring that your dining experiences in this coastal paradise will be nothing short of extraordinary.

So, let's dive in and discover the crème de la crème of seafood in Fort Myers Beach!

Snug Harbor Waterfront Restaurant

Highlights
Friendly bartender
Amazing scallops
Delicious oysters
Outstanding grouper
Must-try Key lime pie

Walking into Snug Harbor, I was immediately greeted by a friendly bartender who made me feel right at home. I quickly settled into one of their comfortable tables and perused the menu, excited to try out their renowned seafood dishes.

I decided to start with the seafood appetizer sampler, which included amazing scallops and delicious oysters. Each bite was a burst of flavor, and I couldn't help but savor every morsel. The freshness of the seafood was undeniable, and I could tell that only the finest ingredients were used.

For my main course, I opted for the outstanding grouper, a local favorite. The fish was perfectly seared, flaky on the inside, and had a delightful hint of lemon. The portion size was generous, and the accompanying vegetables were cooked to perfection.

As the evening wound down, I couldn't resist trying their famous Key lime pie. It was a decision I'll never regret. The pie had a tangy and creamy filling with a buttery graham cracker crust that melted in my mouth. It was the perfect combination of sweet and tart.

All in all, Snug Harbor Waterfront Restaurant truly lives up to its reputation as a top seafood spot in Fort Myers Beach. From the friendly service to the outstanding dishes, every aspect of my experience was exceptional. I highly recommend visiting Snug Harbor for a seafood extravaganza that you won't soon forget!

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in South Myrtle Beach.

The Whale

Highlights
Live music every night
Amazing mac 'n cheese bowl
Comfortable atmosphere
Great view of the beach
Awesome staff

Walking into The Whale, I could immediately sense the lively and comfortable atmosphere that awaited me. The live music playing every night added a fun and festive touch to the place. I took my seat, excited to dive into some delicious seafood.

As I perused the menu, one dish caught my eye - the amazing mac 'n cheese bowl. Let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The cheesy goodness was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of tanginess. It was a true comfort food indulgence that satisfied my taste buds.

Aside from the delectable mac 'n cheese, the seafood offerings at The Whale were exceptional. The freshness of the seafood was undeniable, and I couldn't resist trying their signature dish. The great view of the beach served as a pleasant backdrop while I savored the mouthwatering flavors.

What truly sets The Whale apart is its staff. From the moment I walked in, I felt incredibly welcomed. The team was attentive, well-informed, and genuinely passionate about their craft. Their outstanding service added a personal touch to the overall dining experience.

In conclusion, The Whale is a gem among Fort Myers Beach's seafood scene. Its live music, delicious mac 'n cheese bowl, comfortable atmosphere, beach view, and awesome staff create a winning combination that will leave seafood enthusiasts like me seeking more.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Ft Myers Beach.

THE RUDE SHRIMP CO.

Highlights
Beautiful waterfront location
Friendly and attentive service
Amazing food
Live music
Creative use of shipping containers

Nestled along the beautiful waterfront, THE RUDE SHRIMP CO. offers not only breathtaking views but also an unforgettable dining experience. From the moment I stepped foot in this charming seafood establishment, I was greeted with a warm and friendly ambiance that made me feel right at home.

The staff at THE RUDE SHRIMP CO. were attentive, ensuring that my dining experience was impeccable from start to finish. Their friendly demeanor added a touch of hospitality that elevated the overall experience.

But what truly sets this place apart from the rest is the amazing food. Each dish I sampled was a burst of flavor and creativity. From their succulent shrimp dishes to their perfectly grilled fish, THE RUDE SHRIMP CO. certainly knows how to treat seafood right. Every bite was a delightful explosion of taste that left a lasting impression.

To add to the lively atmosphere, there was live music playing, enhancing the dining experience with its toe-tapping tunes. It added a vibrant and energetic vibe, making it impossible not to enjoy the evening.

One unique feature of THE RUDE SHRIMP CO. is its creative use of shipping containers, which added a fun and quirky touch to the overall setting. It was a refreshing departure from the ordinary and added to the establishment's charm.

Overall, my experience at THE RUDE SHRIMP CO. was a true delight. The stunning waterfront location, attentive service, amazing food, live music, and creative atmosphere all contributed to an unforgettable evening. It's no wonder why this place is considered one of the best seafood spots in Fort Myers Beach. I highly recommend visiting THE RUDE SHRIMP CO. to indulge in a seafood feast that will leave you craving for more.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in North Myrtle Beach.

Pinchers

Hey folks, as a seafood connoisseur, I ventured over to Pinchers in Fort Myers Beach for a taste sensation. Let me tell you, this place is the reel deal. Every bite of their fresh catches had me hooked, and the vibrant flavors danced on my taste buds like mermaids at a beach bonfire. So, if you're in the hunt for the best seafood in Fort Myers Beach, Pinchers is a must-visit.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in North Myrtle Beach.

Fresh Catch Bistro

Fresh Catch Bistro in Fort Myers Beach is an absolute hidden gem when it comes to seafood. Their delectable dishes are bursting with flavor, leaving you wanting more. From their succulent lobster tails to their perfectly cooked blackened grouper, every bite is a seafood lover's dream. Make sure to save room for dessert, their key lime pie is a slice of paradise. Fresh Catch Bistro deserves a spot on the top of any seafood lover's list in Fort Myers Beach.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in South Jersey.

Junkanoo Below Deck

Junkanoo Below Deck, oh what a delight! From the moment I stepped onto their deck, I knew I was in for a seafood extravaganza. The playful atmosphere was infectious, and the food was nothing short of divine. Each bite of crispy fried shrimp and tender grilled fish was a burst of coastal flavor. I cannot recommend this place enough for seafood enthusiasts looking for a standout dining experience in Fort Myers Beach.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Southport NC.

Dixie Fish Company

I had the pleasure of dining at Dixie Fish Company in Fort Myers Beach, and without a doubt, their seafood is something to write home about. From the succulent shrimp to the mouthwatering lobster, every bite was a burst of flavor that left me wanting more. The atmosphere was playful and casual, with a touch of elegance that made me feel right at home. The attentive staff was knowledgeable and friendly, ensuring that my dining experience was nothing short of exceptional. If you're searching for the best seafood in Fort Myers Beach, look no further than Dixie Fish Company. They truly know their way around the ocean's delicacies.

You might also want to check out the best seafood market in Fort Myers.

Doc Ford's Rum Bar & Grille - Ft. Myers Beach

Doc Ford's Rum Bar & Grille in Fort Myers Beach is a playful yet professional seafood haven. With an extensive menu, their dishes are bursting with flavors that will tickle your taste buds. Don't miss their captivating fish tacos and scrumptious peel-and-eat shrimp. It's the perfect spot to indulge in a seafood feast!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Old Orchard Beach.

Matanzas on the Bay

After indulging in the finest selection of seafood at Matanzas on the Bay, I can confidently declare it a true gem on Fort Myers Beach. Their menu is a cornucopia of delectable options that will satisfy even the most discerning palates. From succulent shrimp to melt-in-your-mouth crab cakes, each dish is a testament to their dedication to quality. You'd be remiss not to try their signature lobster bisque, a velvety delight that transcends culinary boundaries. With a picturesque waterfront location and friendly staff, Matanzas on the Bay is a seafood paradise that deserves its spot in the article about the best seafood in Fort Myers Beach.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Fort Myers Florida.

Bonita Bills Waterfront Cafe

Bonita Bills Waterfront Cafe in Fort Myers Beach is a hidden gem for seafood lovers! The playful atmosphere and friendly staff create a relaxed dining experience. The fresh and flavorful seafood options will make your taste buds dance with joy. Don't miss the crispy calamari and the succulent shrimp dishes. A must-visit for seafood enthusiasts!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Myrtle Beach.

Parrot Key Caribbean Grill

Parrot Key Caribbean Grill in Fort Myers Beach is a seafood lover's paradise! From their mouthwatering coconut shrimp to their delicious seafood platters, this place knows how to satisfy those seafood cravings. The laid-back atmosphere and friendly staff make it the perfect spot for a seafood feast. Don't miss out on their flavorful fish tacos and refreshing rum punches. It's a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts in Fort Myers Beach!

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Myrtle Beach.

The Yucatan Beach Stand

The Yucatan Beach Stand in Fort Myers Beach has definitely won me over with their playfully delicious seafood options. From their succulent shrimp tacos to their perfectly grilled mahi-mahi, every bite left me wanting more. With a relaxed beachside atmosphere and outstanding service, it's a must-visit spot for seafood lovers.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Orange Beach.