The Absolute Best Seafood in Jersey [Updated 2024]

Having reviewed a total of 12 exquisite seafood establishments, I have meticulously assessed each one to ensure that only the absolute best are featured in this comprehensive guide. Whether you are a seafood connoisseur or a casual diner seeking a memorable culinary experience, this article is your go-to resource.

I have meticulously scoured every nook and cranny of Jersey, sampling an array of delectable dishes, diving deep into the local seafood scene. From succulent lobster and plump oysters to mouthwatering crab cakes and fresh fish straight from the Atlantic, get ready to embark on a gastronomic journey like no other.

Bahrs Landing Famous Seafood Restaurant & Marina

Highlights
Fresh and delicious
Excellent service
Historic ambiance
Fun gift shop
Great seafood variety

Walking into Bahrs Landing, I was immediately greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere that perfectly complemented its historic setting. The restaurant, with its nautical decor and breathtaking waterfront views, exudes a certain charm that transports you back to the golden age of Jersey's seafaring history.

As I settled in, I was impressed by the excellent service provided by the attentive staff who seemed genuinely passionate about the food and ensuring a memorable dining experience. With their extensive knowledge, they guided me through the menu, highlighting the freshest catches of the day. The menu boasted a wide array of seafood options, catering to every taste and preference.

I indulged in a plate of fresh and delicious lobster, which was cooked to perfection. The meat was tender, succulent, and melted in my mouth, leaving a lingering flavor that I savored with each bite. The accompanying sides, such as the creamy coleslaw and crispy fries, only elevated the dish further.

After relishing the delightful seafood feast, I couldn't resist browsing the restaurant's fun gift shop, brimming with maritime-themed souvenirs and local treasures. It was the perfect way to extend my Bahrs Landing experience beyond the dining table.

All in all, Bahrs Landing is a must-visit seafood destination in Jersey. Its combination of exceptional service, historic ambiance, and great seafood variety ensures an unforgettable dining experience. So, if you're in the mood for mouthwatering seafood and an esteemed maritime atmosphere, make sure to set sail for Bahrs Landing Famous Seafood Restaurant & Marina!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in South Jersey.

Catch 19

Highlights
Fresh oysters
Delicious fish
Tasty sea bass
Friendly service
Excellent location

Catch 19 in Jersey is a hidden gem that offers a delightful seafood experience. As soon as I entered the restaurant, I was greeted by a warm and friendly staff, which immediately set the tone for the evening.

The menu at Catch 19 boasts an impressive selection of seafood delicacies, and I couldn't resist starting off with some fresh oysters. Served on a bed of ice, the oysters were incredibly plump and briny, bursting with a refreshing sea flavor that reminded me of being by the seaside.

Moving on to the main course, I opted for the catch of the day. The fish was cooked to perfection, with a crispy skin that gave way to tender, moist flesh. The flavors were well-balanced, allowing the natural taste of the fish to shine through.

But the highlight of my meal was definitely the sea bass. It was succulent and flaky, with a buttery richness that melted in my mouth. The dish was beautifully presented, showcasing the artistry of the chef.

Throughout my dining experience, the service remained top-notch. The staff was knowledgeable about the menu and offered helpful suggestions. They were attentive without being intrusive, creating a relaxed and enjoyable atmosphere.

Situated in an excellent location, Catch 19 provides a wonderful waterfront view. It's perfect for a romantic dinner or a gathering with friends. With its combination of delicious seafood, friendly service, and scenic setting, Catch 19 truly embodies the best of Jersey's seafood scene.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Worcester.

2nd Jetty Seafood

Highlights
Impressed dinner
Good food service
Great food drinks
Laid-back vibe
Gets packed

As I walked into 2nd Jetty Seafood, I was immediately impressed by the lively and laid-back vibe of the place. The aroma of fresh seafood permeated the air, igniting my appetite and anticipation for what was to come.

The dinner service was prompt and attentive, making sure our needs were met throughout the entire meal. The waitstaff were friendly and knowledgeable about the menu, providing excellent recommendations for both food and drinks. Speaking of drinks, they have a great selection to accompany your meal, from refreshing craft beers to expertly mixed cocktails.

Now let's get to the star of the show: the food. Oh, boy! The moment our orders arrived, I knew we were in for a treat. The seafood was impeccably fresh and mouthwateringly delicious. Each dish was expertly prepared, showcasing the natural flavors of the ocean's bounty. From the succulent lobster to the perfectly seared scallops, every bite was a delightful seafood symphony.

But beware, my friend. Such high-quality fare comes with a price. As word has spread about this seafood gem, it tends to get packed at peak times. So, it's best to plan your visit accordingly or be prepared to exercise a little patience.

Overall, my visit to 2nd Jetty Seafood left me with a delightful taste of the ocean and a desire to return for more. The combination of impressive dinner service, delicious food and drinks, and the restaurant's laid-back vibe place it firmly on my list of the top seafood spots in Jersey. So, grab your appetite and pay a visit to 2nd Jetty Seafood - the ocean's bounty awaits!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rochester NY.

Off The Hook Restaurant and Bar

Off The Hook Restaurant and Bar in Jersey is a hidden treasure for seafood enthusiasts. The vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff set the stage for a delightful dining experience. The menu boasts an impressive array of ocean delights, from succulent lobster tails to mouthwatering grilled shrimp. Don't miss their divine crab cake appetizer; it's a game-changer. Don't overlook this gem when seeking the best seafood in Jersey!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Port Jefferson.

Inlet Cafe

Inlet Cafe in Jersey is a seafood haven that left me hooked. With its playful atmosphere and stellar service, this spot delivers on every level. From the succulent lobster to their mouthwatering clam chowder, prepare to be wowed. Don't forget to snap a pic with their picturesque waterfront view!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Martha's Vineyard.

Lusty Lobster

When I stepped into Lusty Lobster in Jersey, I was immediately greeted by the tantalizing aroma of fresh seafood. The staff provided exceptional service, guiding me through their extensive selection of mouthwatering lobsters and delectable shellfish. With each bite, I was transported to seafood paradise. This place truly deserves its spot among the best seafood eateries in Jersey.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Manchester NH.

Navesink Fishery

Navesink Fishery in Jersey is a hidden gem when it comes to seafood. From succulent lobster rolls to flawlessly fried shrimp, every bite was a salty bliss. The playful and friendly atmosphere coupled with their impeccable service made it a perfect spot for seafood lovers.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Atlantic City New Jersey.

Rooney's Oceanfront Restaurant

Rooney's Oceanfront Restaurant delivered an oceanic delight that danced upon my taste buds. The freshness of their seafood had me shouting "holy shellfish!" The succulent lobster and crispy calamari were divine. With a spectacular view to match, Rooney's is the destination for seafood aficionados in Jersey.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Boston.

The High Seafood

The High Seafood in Jersey blew me away with their delectable seafood offerings! From the succulent lobster to the divine oysters, every bite was a burst of oceanic bliss. The playful yet professional ambiance added an extra touch of enjoyment to the already breathtaking experience. Don't miss out on this shorely amazing culinary adventure!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Baltimore.

Cuzin's Seafood & Clam Bar

I must say, Cuzin's Seafood & Clam Bar in Jersey left me speechless - and trust me, that's quite a feat! Fresh seafood, flavorful dishes, and friendly staff made this place stand out. The crispy fried clams and succulent lobster tail were definite highlights. Seafood lovers rejoice - Cuzin's is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Ocean City MD.

The BoonDocks Fishery

The BoonDocks Fishery in Jersey is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. Their playful yet professional atmosphere is as enticing as their menu. From the buttery lobster rolls to the delectable crab cakes, every bite is a taste of maritime bliss. Trust me, this place will have you hooked!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Portsmouth NH.

On the Deck

On the Deck in Jersey is a seafood paradise that will make your taste buds dance with joy. The menu boasts an array of fresh catches that are cooked to perfection. From succulent lobster to delicate crab cakes, every bite is an explosion of flavor. The playful atmosphere adds to the overall experience, making it a top contender for the best seafood spot in Jersey.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rehoboth Beach.