Keywest's Best Seafood [Updated 2024]

With a total of 12 seafood restaurants reviewed, my mission was to scrutinize and discern the true gems that offer a remarkable culinary experience. Having explored every nook and cranny of Key West, I can confidently assure you that this comprehensive guide will steer you towards the most delectable seafood dishes this vibrant island has to offer.

From succulent shrimp and flaky fish tacos to mouthwatering crab cakes and divine lobster rolls, prepare yourself for a culinary adventure like no other. So buckle up and embark on this seafood journey with me as we uncover the hidden treasures of Key West's Best Seafood!

Conch Republic Seafood Company

Highlights
Friendly staff
Fantastic welcome
Beautiful location
Delicious food
Great Bloody Mary

I must say, my visit to Conch Republic Seafood Company truly lived up to its reputation as one of the best seafood spots in Keywest. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a friendly staff with a fantastic welcome that instantly put me in a playful vacation mood.

The restaurant itself is situated in a beautiful location, overlooking the sparkling blue waters of Keywest. I couldn't have asked for a better backdrop for my seafood feast. The spacious outdoor seating area added an extra charm to the whole dining experience.

Now let's talk about the star of the show—the food. Oh my, the food! The menu at Conch Republic Seafood Company is a seafood lover's dream come true. I indulged in a variety of dishes, from the classic Key West pink shrimp to the mouthwatering local catch of the day. Each bite was a burst of flavor that transported me to seafood paradise.

One dish that deserves a special mention is their Bloody Mary. It was the perfect combination of spicy and tangy, accompanied by a delicious garnish that left me craving for more.

Overall, my visit to Conch Republic Seafood Company was a delectable experience. The friendly staff, fantastic welcome, beautiful location, and above all, the delicious food make it a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts like myself. So, if you find yourself in Keywest, do yourself a favor and experience the seafood extravaganza at Conch Republic Seafood Company.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in South Jersey.

Eaton Street Seafood Market

Highlights
Fresh seafood
Tasty lobster roll
Friendly and helpful staff
Outdoor seating with shade
Locally caught fish and shrimp

Upon entering the bustling Eaton Street Seafood Market, I was immediately captivated by the enticing aromas that filled the air. The market prides itself on offering the freshest seafood, and boy, did they deliver! From the moment I took my first bite, I could tell that the seafood here was of the highest quality.

One standout dish that stole the show was their tasty lobster roll. Bursting with succulent chunks of lobster, perfectly mixed with a hint of mayo, and served on a buttery, toasted roll, it was a seafood lover's delight. The lobster was incredibly tender, and the flavors danced harmoniously on my palate with each bite.

But what truly made my experience remarkable was the staff. They were not only friendly and welcoming but also extremely knowledgeable. They took the time to explain the different seafood options, provide cooking tips, and even shared stories about the local fishermen. Their passion for seafood shone through their every word.

To top it all off, Eaton Street Seafood Market offers a delightful outdoor seating area, complete with shade to shield you from the sun. It's the perfect spot to enjoy your meal while taking in the scenic surroundings.

What truly sets Eaton Street Seafood Market apart is their commitment to sourcing locally caught fish and shrimp. This way, you know that every bite supports the community and ensures you're getting the freshest catch of the day.

If you're looking for the best seafood in Keywest, Eaton Street Seafood Market unquestionably deserves a spot at the top of your must-visit list. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Southern Maine.

Pinchers

Highlights
Delicious crab legs
Great service
Happy hour specials
Live music

Let me start by saying that Pinchers is a true seafood lover's paradise! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm and friendly atmosphere. The first thing that caught my eye was the delicious crab legs being served at almost every table. I couldn't resist getting an order for myself.

The flavor of the crab legs was absolutely divine. They were tender and succulent, cooked to perfection. The meat practically melted in my mouth, leaving me craving for more. It's no wonder why they have such a reputation for their seafood.

Another aspect that impressed me was the great service. The staff at Pinchers were prompt and attentive, making sure that I had everything I needed to enjoy my meal. They were also knowledgeable about the menu and offered excellent recommendations.

One thing that really stood out to me was the happy hour specials. Not only did they have a wide selection of drinks, but the prices were also incredibly reasonable. It made the whole experience even more enjoyable.

To top it all off, there was live music playing in the background, creating a lively and vibrant atmosphere. It added an extra touch of excitement to my dining experience.

In conclusion, if you're looking for top-tier seafood in Keywest, Pinchers is a must-visit. With their delicious crab legs, great service, happy hour specials, and live music, you'll be in for an unforgettable seafood feast.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Monmouth County.

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

Located in the heart of Keywest, The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. is a delightful seafood establishment that brings a playful twist to the dining experience. The inventive menu boasts a variety of fresh catches, expertly prepared by a passionate team of chefs. With every bite, I was transported to seafood heaven. Bold flavors and innovative dishes tantalize the taste buds, leaving you wanting more. The atmosphere is vibrant and welcoming, making it the perfect spot for a memorable seafood feast. For an unforgettable culinary adventure, make sure to visit The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Boston.

Stinkin Crawfish Key West

Hey there seafood lovers! As I ventured out to explore the best seafood in Keywest, I stumbled upon a hidden gem called Stinkin Crawfish Key West. Nestled in the heart of Keywest, this playful yet professional seafood joint is a must-visit. With bold flavors and a lively atmosphere, it's like a party for your taste buds! The menu boasts a delectable array of seafood options including fresh crawfish, succulent shrimp, and melt-in-your-mouth crab. Trust me, their Cajun-inspired dishes will have you craving for more! And let's not forget their signature garlic butter sauce - a true game-changer. So, if you're in Keywest and seeking a seafood experience that balances fun and quality, make sure to stop by Stinkin Crawfish Key West. It's a seafood sensation you won't want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Baltimore.

Schooner Wharf Bar

Schooner Wharf Bar in Keywest is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. With its vibrant atmosphere and stunning waterfront view, this place is a seafood paradise. The tasty and fresh seafood selections, such as their succulent lobster rolls and flavorful conch fritters, will tantalize your taste buds. Don't forget to pair it with their zesty cocktails for the ultimate seafood feast!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Ocean City MD.

"Off The Hook" Grill

I was beyond hooked on the seafood offerings at "Off The Hook" Grill in Keywest! The playful yet professional atmosphere perfectly complements the delectable dishes. From the succulent fresh oysters to the tasty lobster rolls, every bite was a burst of flavorful bliss. Don't let this gem slip away!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Portsmouth NH.

B.O.'s Fish Wagon

B.O.'s Fish Wagon in Keywest is a hidden gem that delivers unforgettable seafood. From their succulent fried shrimp to their mouthwatering lobster rolls, every bite is a party for your taste buds. The laid-back atmosphere and friendly staff make this spot a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rehoboth Beach.

Half Shell Raw Bar

Nestled in the heart of Keywest, Half Shell Raw Bar is a seafood lover's paradise. With its laid-back atmosphere and deliciously fresh dishes, this hidden gem never fails to impress. From succulent oysters to mouthwatering crab cakes, each bite is a burst of flavor. Don't forget to try their signature Key Lime Pie for a sweet ending to your meal. Whether you're a local or a tourist, Half Shell Raw Bar is a must-visit for an unforgettable seafood experience.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Gloucester MA.

A&B Lobster House

A&B Lobster House is a hidden treasure in Keywest's seafood scene, offering a delightful culinary journey. The impeccable service, refined ambiance, and the freshest catches from the sea made my taste buds dance with joy. Don't miss their succulent lobster bisque and scrumptious seafood platter. It's a seafood lover's paradise!

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Ocean City MD.

Thirsty Mermaid

Thirsty Mermaid in Keywest is a seafood haven that will satisfy even the most discerning palates. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a lively yet laid-back atmosphere. The menu boasted a variety of mouthwatering dishes, but their oysters stole the show. The briny, succulent goodness of each bite transported me straight to the ocean. Thirsty Mermaid is definitely a treasure worth diving into!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in New England.

Turtle Kraals

I can confidently say that Turtle Kraals is a hidden gem in the realm of Keywest seafood. The freshness of their dishes is unmatched, and their playful menu offers a delightful twist on traditional seafood favorites. From their succulent Key West pink shrimp to their mouthwatering conch fritters, Turtle Kraals serves up a delectable coastal feast. With its vibrant atmosphere and friendly service, Turtle Kraals is definitely a must-visit spot for seafood lovers in Keywest.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rochester NY.