The Absolute Best Seafood Market in Hilton Head [Updated 2024]

Having reviewed a total of 12 seafood markets in Hilton Head, I am excited to share my expertise on the best one with you. While exploring the coastal beauty of Hilton Head, I couldn't resist indulging in its bountiful seafood offerings.

After carefully evaluating each market, one establishment has proven to outshine the rest, both in terms of quality and selection. Whether you are a seafood enthusiast or a culinary connoisseur, joining me on this journey will unveil an unparalleled seafood experience.

So, without further ado, let's dive into the exceptional realm of the best seafood market in Hilton Head.

Benny Hudson Seafood

Highlights
Local and fresh
Knowledgeable
Quality fish
Friendly service
Great shrimp

Walking into Benny Hudson Seafood, I immediately felt the local and fresh vibes. The ambiance was inviting, with a delightful aroma of the sea lingering in the air. The staff was not only friendly but also incredibly knowledgeable about their offerings, allowing me to explore various options confidently.

One thing that truly stood out was the exceptional quality of the fish. Each fillet was displayed beautifully, glistening with freshness. I couldn't resist but try a fillet of their famous local snapper, and boy, did it deliver! The fish was flaky, moist, and exploded with flavors, proving that Benny Hudson Seafood knows their fish inside out.

What really charmed me was their remarkable service. The staff went above and beyond to answer all my questions, recommending their favorite recipes and sharing cooking tips. Their passion for seafood was contagious, making the whole experience even more enjoyable.

Oh, and let's not forget about their shrimp! It was a great addition to my basket. Plump, succulent, and full of flavor—I couldn't have asked for more.

If you're searching for the best seafood market in Hilton Head, Benny Hudson Seafood ticks all the boxes. With their commitment to freshness, knowledgeable staff, quality offerings, and friendly service, this place is definitely a catch.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Hilton Head SC.

Carolina Crab Co

Highlights
Great experience
Friendly service
Fresh and hot food
Accommodations for special needs
Moderately priced

Walking into Carolina Crab Co was like stepping into seafood heaven. The atmosphere was lively, with the smell of fresh seafood wafting through the air. It was a great experience from start to finish.

The friendly service was a standout. The staff greeted us with big smiles and were happy to answer any questions we had about the menu. They even took the time to accommodate my friend's dietary restrictions, ensuring she had a memorable meal.

Now let's talk about the food - oh my, it was divine! Every bite was bursting with flavor, and you could tell the seafood was fresh and hot. From the succulent shrimp to the perfectly cooked crab legs, it was a feast fit for a seafood lover.

Another aspect that impressed me was the moderately priced menu. Despite the high-quality seafood, the prices were reasonable, making it accessible to a wider range of diners. It's refreshing to find a place where you don't have to break the bank for a delicious seafood meal.

Overall, Carolina Crab Co exceeded my expectations. The combination of great atmosphere, friendly service, accommodations for special needs, and outstanding seafood make it a top contender for the best seafood market in Hilton Head. Whether you're a local or a tourist, make sure to add Carolina Crab Co to your seafood bucket list.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Hilton Head Island SC.

FISH Casual Coastal Seafood

Highlights
Wonderful atmosphere
Fast food service
Fresh oysters
Delicious baked oysters
Affordable prices

I have to say, the atmosphere at FISH was simply wonderful. As soon as I entered, I was greeted by the sight of a cozy and lively restaurant. The decor was tastefully nautical, with beautiful paintings of underwater scenes adorning the walls, and the sound of soft waves playing in the background. It truly felt like a coastal retreat.

But let's get to the important stuff - the food. The fast service at FISH was impressive. Within minutes of placing my order, a plate of fresh, glistening oysters was in front of me. These oysters were truly a treat for the taste buds. They were so fresh, you could practically taste the sea with each bite.

Now, let's talk about these baked oysters. Oh my, they were simply delicious. The oysters were baked to perfection, with a delicate balance of flavors that danced on my tongue. The combination of savory butter, garlic, and a hint of lemon made each bite an absolute delight.

And if all of that isn't enough, the prices at FISH were surprisingly affordable. I was pleasantly surprised at how reasonably priced the seafood was, especially considering the quality and freshness.

All in all, my experience at FISH Casual Coastal Seafood was a delight for both my senses and my wallet. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a top-notch seafood market in Hilton Head.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Hilton Head.

Old Oyster Factory Restaurant

Old Oyster Factory Restaurant in Hilton Head is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. The tantalizing aroma of grilled shrimp and the succulent taste of freshly shucked oysters transports you to seafood paradise. The playfully vintage atmosphere adds to the charm. Don't miss out on their delectable seafood offerings!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Bluffton.

Hudson's Seafood House On The Docks

Hudson's Seafood House On The Docks in Hilton Head is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. With its rustic charm and ocean views, it provides the perfect setting to indulge in fresh and delicious seafood. From their mouthwatering crab cakes to their succulent shrimp, every bite is a delight. Don't miss out on their famous firecracker shrimp, a spicy explosion of flavors. The friendly and attentive staff make the dining experience even more enjoyable. Make sure to visit Hudson's Seafood House On The Docks for an unforgettable seafood feast.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Beaufort SC.

Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar

Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar in Hilton Head is a seafood lover's paradise. The lively atmosphere and friendly staff create an inviting environment. The seafood is fresh and bursting with flavor, especially the Cajun-spiced shrimp. Don't miss their signature crab boil - it's an absolute must-try!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Tybee Island.

Barnacle Bill's Fresh Seafood

Barnacle Bill's Fresh Seafood in Hilton Head is a truly hidden gem! From the moment I stepped in, I was greeted by the aroma of the freshest catch in town. The bustling atmosphere gave me a sense of excitement. Their knowledgeable staff guided me in selecting the perfect seafood for my family's dinner. The selection was impressive, with a variety of finned delights that would satisfy even the most discerning seafood connoisseur. And the best part? The quality and freshness of their seafood were unmatched! Whether you're a local or a visitor, make sure to swing by Barnacle Bill's for an unforgettable experience. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Downtown Savannah.

South End Seafood

In my quest to find the best seafood market in Hilton Head, I ventured into South End Seafood expecting nothing short of a culinary adventure. And boy, did they deliver! From their fresh catches to their charming staff, this place is a seafood lover's dream come true. Don't shrimp out on a visit!

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Savannah GA.

Spanish Wells Seafood & Produce

Spanish Wells Seafood & Produce in Hilton Head is a hidden gem for seafood enthusiasts. With a playful yet professional atmosphere, this market offers a dazzling array of fresh catches, from succulent shrimp to delectable crab. The bold flavors and italics quality of their products make it a must-visit for any seafood lover in Hilton Head.

You might also want to check out the best cheap seafood in Savannah GA.

Scott's Fish Market Restaurant & Bar

I must say, Scott's Fish Market Restaurant & Bar is a seafood paradise. The ambience is lively, the service is top-notch, and the food is absolutely delicious. Whether you're craving crab legs or shrimp scampi, Scott's has it all. Don't miss out on their fresh catches and tempting cocktails. It's definitely a must-visit seafood market in Hilton Head!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Savannah.

Beautiful Island Square

I was absolutely blown away by Beautiful Island Square in Hilton Head. From the charming ambiance to the impressive selection of fresh seafood, this market is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. The staff were incredibly friendly and knowledgeable, helping me make the perfect choice for my meal. Whether you're a local or a tourist, Beautiful Island Square is an absolute must-visit for anyone looking for the best seafood in Hilton Head.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Savannah.

The Fresh Market

The Fresh Market in Hilton Head was an oceanic delight! I was hooked by their impressive variety of fresh seafood, from succulent shrimp to mouthwatering grouper. The knowledgeable staff reeled me in with their professional recommendations, making my seafood shopping a fin-tastic experience. Out-of-towners and locals alike, this is THE place to reel in some delicious seafood!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Edisto Beach SC.