The Absolute Best Seafood in Boothbay Harbor Maine [Updated 2024]

Having personally reviewed a total of 12 seafood establishments in Boothbay Harbor Maine, I have narrowed down the seemingly endless options to bring you only the crème de la crème. With my vast expertise and deep-rooted passion for seafood, I can confidently unveil the hidden gems that should not be missed in this charming coastal town.

Whether you are a local resident or a visitor seeking an unforgettable culinary experience, this article will provide you with an insider's look at the most delectable and freshest seafood offerings that Boothbay Harbor Maine has to offer. Prepare yourself for a journey of gastronomic delight as we explore the best seafood this picturesque harbor town has in store for you!

Mine Oyster

Highlights
Nice view
Tuna tartare
Lobster stew
Lobster rolls

Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately captivated by the nice view it offered. The windows allowed for a breathtaking sight of the harbor, making my dining experience all the more enjoyable.

Now, let's talk about the tuna tartare. Delicately assembled with freshness in every bite, this appetizer won me over. The delicate blend of flavors and textures truly showcased the expertise of the chef. It was like a perfectly choreographed dance of taste on my palate.

Next, I indulged in the lobster stew. This creamy and flavorful concoction was a true highlight of the meal. The chunks of succulent lobster paired harmoniously with the rich broth, creating an explosion of flavors that left me craving more.

And of course, how could I forget about the lobster rolls? A classic staple in coastal Maine cuisine. Mine Oyster exceeded my expectations with their version. The rolls were filled to perfection with generous amounts of tender lobster meat, and served with a side of crispy fries. It was a delectable experience that made me feel like I was dining by the seaside.

Overall, Mine Oyster in Boothbay Harbor Maine is a seafood lover's dream. The nice view, the exquisite tuna tartare, the mouthwatering lobster stew, and the divine lobster rolls make it one of the top seafood destinations in the area. Don't miss the chance to savor the flavors of the sea at this charming and delicious establishment.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Bar Harbor Maine.

Tugboat Restaurant

Highlights
Quirky atmosphere
Tugboat dining experience
Amazing lobster bisque
Delicious seafood Alfredo

When I first stepped into Tugboat Restaurant, I was immediately greeted by a quirky atmosphere that transported me back to the days of sailboats and seafaring adventures. The interior is filled with nautical decor, creating a cozy and inviting ambiance.

The Tugboat dining experience itself was unforgettable. The staff was welcoming and attentive, making sure I had everything I needed throughout my meal. The service had a personal touch that truly made me feel like a valued guest.

Now, let's get to the main event - the food. The lobster bisque at Tugboat Restaurant was simply extraordinary. Every spoonful was packed with the rich flavors of fresh lobster, creating a velvety smooth soup that was out of this world. It was truly a taste of the ocean in every bite.

But that's not all. The seafood Alfredo is a dish that seafood lovers should not miss. The combination of tender shrimp, succulent scallops, and perfectly cooked pasta smothered in a creamy Alfredo sauce was a heavenly creation that left me craving for more.

In conclusion, Tugboat Restaurant in Boothbay Harbor Maine offers an exceptional seafood dining experience. From the quirky atmosphere to the amazing lobster bisque and delicious seafood Alfredo, this restaurant has truly earned its spot as one of the best seafood establishments in the area. So, if you find yourself in Boothbay Harbor, be sure to hop aboard the Tugboat and indulge in their delectable offerings.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Boston.

The Carousel Marina / The Whale's Tale & Seafarer's Pub

Highlights
Attentive staff
Delicious seafood
Unique menu
Friendly atmosphere

Let me start off by saying that the friendly atmosphere at The Carousel Marina / The Whale's Tale & Seafarer's Pub was absolutely delightful. From the moment I walked in, the attentive staff made me feel like I was part of their maritime family.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the seafood. Oh my goodness, the seafood here is not just good, it's out of this world! The flavors were so fresh and vibrant, I felt like I was tasting the essence of the ocean with every bite. Whether it was the succulent lobsters or the juicy scallops, every dish left me wanting more.

What sets The Carousel Marina / The Whale's Tale & Seafarer's Pub apart from other seafood spots in Boothbay Harbor Maine is their unique menu. They have creatively reimagined classic seafood dishes with exciting twists, like their lobster roll with a tangy citrus aioli or their seared scallops with a zesty mango salsa. Each dish was a burst of flavors that had my taste buds dancing with joy.

But it's not just about the food. The atmosphere here is laid-back and welcoming, creating the perfect setting for a memorable seafood experience. Whether you're dining with friends or enjoying a meal on your own, the cozy ambiance of this establishment adds an extra layer of enjoyment to the culinary adventure.

In conclusion, my visit to The Carousel Marina / The Whale's Tale & Seafarer's Pub was an absolute delight. With their attentive staff, delicious seafood, unique menu, and friendly atmosphere, it's no wonder it's considered one of the best seafood spots in Boothbay Harbor Maine. If you're visiting the area, do yourself a favor and indulge in a seafood feast at this charming establishment.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Baltimore.

Ports of Italy, Boothbay Harbor

Ports of Italy, Boothbay Harbor in Boothbay Harbor Maine was a seafood delight. The tantalizing flavors of their dishes transported me straight to the Italian coast. The freshness of their seafood was evident in every bite. A must-visit for any seafood lover in Boothbay Harbor!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Ocean City MD.

The Deck Bar & Grill

The Deck Bar & Grill in Boothbay Harbor Maine is a seafood lover's paradise. With its stunning waterfront views and delectable menu, this place is a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts. From the mouthwatering lobster rolls to the succulent clam chowder, every bite was a flavorful masterpiece. Don't forget to try their crispy fried shrimp, it's absolute perfection. The Deck Bar & Grill truly knows how to satisfy seafood cravings while providing a delightful dining experience.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Portsmouth NH.

Kaler's Restaurant

Summary review of Kaler's Restaurant in Boothbay Harbor Maine: Kaler's Restaurant in Boothbay Harbor Maine is a delightful seafood spot with a playful yet professional atmosphere. The menu offers a varied selection of fresh and flavorful dishes. From succulent lobster rolls to perfectly grilled scallops, every bite at Kaler's is a taste of seafood paradise.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rehoboth Beach.

McSeagull’s Restaurant

McSeagull's Restaurant in Boothbay Harbor Maine truly captivated my taste buds with their scrumptious seafood dishes. The playful atmosphere combined with their exquisite culinary skills made every bite a delightful adventure. A must-try for seafood enthusiasts!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Gloucester MA.

Boathouse Bistro Tapas Bar & Restaurant

Boathouse Bistro Tapas Bar & Restaurant is a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Boothbay Harbor. Their seafood dishes are a culinary masterpiece, bursting with flavors that will make your taste buds dance with joy. The freshness of the seafood is palpable in every bite. From the succulent lobster rolls to the perfectly grilled scallops, each dish is a tantalizing treasure from the sea. The elegant ambiance of the restaurant adds a touch of class to your dining experience, making it perfect for a romantic date night or a special celebration. Don't miss the chance to indulge in their mouthwatering seafood creations when you visit Boothbay Harbor. Boathouse Bistro Tapas Bar & Restaurant is a true seafood haven that will leave you craving for more.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Ocean City MD.

HarborSide 1901Bar and Grill

I took a delightful dive into the seafood offerings at HarborSide 1901Bar and Grill, a lively spot in Boothbay Harbor Maine. Their menu is a seafood lover's dream, featuring fresh catches prepared with flair and finesse. Don't miss out on their succulent lobster rolls and crispy fried clams. A definite must-try for seafood aficionados!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in New England.

Brady's

Brady's in Boothbay Harbor Maine is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. From fresh lobster to succulent scallops, their menu is a flavorful feast. The crispy fried clams are a must-try, bursting with briny goodness. With friendly service and a charming ambiance, Brady's is a seafood haven in Maine.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rochester NY.

Atlantic Edge Lobster

As an expert seafood reviewer, I recently made my way to the wondrous Atlantic Edge Lobster in Boothbay Harbor Maine, and boy was I blown away! The freshness of their lobster is to die for and the flavor is unmatched. A true hidden gem for seafood lovers!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Hyannis.

Thistle Inn Restaurant

The Thistle Inn Restaurant in Boothbay Harbor Maine is a hidden gem that stole my taste buds and heart. Decked out with a cozy ambience and a touch of maritime charm, this place is seafood heaven. From the crispiness of their fried clams to the tenderness of their lobster, every bite brought me closer to seafood nirvana. The staff, like mermaids of hospitality, were attentive and friendly. And their commitment to freshness? Unparalleled! The Thistle Inn Restaurant is without a doubt a must-try for any seafood aficionado visiting Boothbay Harbor Maine.