The Absolute Best Seafood in Islamorada [Updated 2024]

With my extensive knowledge and expertise in seafood, I have had the pleasure of reviewing 12 incredible seafood establishments in Islamorada. From fine dining to casual seafood shacks, I have carefully handpicked the absolute best spots for seafood lovers.

In this comprehensive guide, I will be sharing my personal recommendations and insights on where to find the freshest catches, the most delightful flavors, and the finest culinary experiences in Islamorada. So, if you're ready to embark on a seafood journey like no other, join me as we uncover the hidden gems and savor the astonishing seafood delights that this charming Florida Keys destination has to offer.

Lazy Days Restaurant

Highlights
Great view
Delicious food
Friendly service
Memorable experience
Amazing banana bread

Walking into Lazy Days Restaurant, I was immediately struck by the great view of the turquoise waters surrounding Islamorada. The outdoor seating area provided the perfect backdrop for a seafood feast.

Oh, where to begin with the food? The menu was filled with a bountiful selection of delicious seafood options. From the succulent lobster tails to the perfectly cooked mahi-mahi, every bite was bursting with flavor. Presentation also played a significant role, as the dishes were beautifully plated and showcased the freshness of the ingredients.

But it wasn't just the food that impressed me; the friendly service added to the overall enjoyment of the meal. The staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely cared about our dining experience. Recommendations were spot-on, ensuring we made the most of the menu.

Eating at Lazy Days Restaurant was not just a meal, it was a memorable experience. The ambiance, the laughter, the warmth of the sun on my skin, all combined to create a delightful evening. Not to forget to mention the delectable banana bread that left my taste buds in awe. It was moist, flavorful, and simply heavenly, making it the perfect end to a seafood feast.

Lazy Days Restaurant in Islamorada truly showcases the best seafood the area has to offer. With its breathtaking view, delightful food, friendly service, and that amazing banana bread, it's no wonder this place is regarded as a must-visit. So hop aboard the seafood journey and let Lazy Days Restaurant take you on a culinary adventure you won't soon forget.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Islamorada.

Island Grill

Highlights
Great waterfront view
Delicious tuna appetizer
Excellent service from Jeissen
Dog and kid friendly
Amazing server Emma

From the moment I walked in, I was captivated by the great waterfront view that Island Grill has to offer. The gentle breeze from the ocean and the soothing sound of waves made for a delightful dining atmosphere.

Now let's talk about the food. The tuna appetizer was simply scrumptious. The perfectly seared slices of tuna were served with a tangy soy ginger sauce that made my taste buds dance with joy. It was a delightful start to my seafood adventure.

What really stood out about my visit was the excellent service provided by Jeissen. He was knowledgeable, friendly, and went above and beyond to ensure that my dining experience was top-notch. Kudos to him for making me feel like a valued customer.

One thing that cannot go unnoticed is that Island Grill is both dog and kid friendly. It was heartwarming to see families enjoying a meal together, with their furry friends by their side. It truly added to the lively and welcoming ambiance of the restaurant.

Lastly, I have to give a shoutout to my amazing server, Emma. She was attentive, personable, and made sure all my needs were met throughout the evening. Her warm smile and genuine enthusiasm added an extra touch of magic to my dining experience.

In conclusion, Island Grill has made its mark on the seafood scene in Islamorada. With its picturesque waterfront setting, delectable tuna appetizer, excellent service from Jeissen, and the presence of Emma as an amazing server, it certainly deserves a spot on the list of the best seafood restaurants in Islamorada. So, if you're in the area and craving some delicious seafood, Island Grill should be on your must-visit list.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in South Florida.

Morada Bay

Highlights
Amazing sunset
Beachfront location
Friendly staff
Delicious food
Beautiful view

Morada Bay provides a seafood dining experience that is as captivating as the sunset views it offers. Nestled in an idyllic beachfront location, this restaurant serves up a delightful fusion of flavors that will leave your taste buds dancing.

From the moment I arrived, the warm and welcoming atmosphere was evident in the friendly smiles of the staff. They made me feel like an honored guest, offering attentive and personalized service throughout my dining experience.

Now let's talk about the star of the show: the delicious seafood. The menu featured an impressive selection of fresh catches, prepared with skill and creativity. Each dish was more tantalizing than the last, showcasing the delicate flavors of the sea in a variety of mouthwatering ways. From the perfectly seasoned grilled fish to the succulent lobster tail, the seafood at Morada Bay did not disappoint.

But it wasn't just the food that left a lasting impression. As I savored each delectable bite, I was treated to a beautiful view of the crystal-clear waters, where the colors of the sunset danced across the horizon. It was a truly magical setting that heightened the dining experience.

In conclusion, Morada Bay is a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts in Islamorada. With its amazing sunset, beachfront location, friendly staff, delicious food, and beautiful view, it offers a dining experience that is both memorable and exceptional. So, if you're searching for the best seafood in Islamorada, look no further than Morada Bay.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in South Padre.

Atlantic's Edge Restaurant

Atlantic's Edge Restaurant in Islamorada is a seafood lover's paradise. With its amazing coastal ambiance and a menu that is teeming with culinary gems, this restaurant is a must-visit for discerning seafood enthusiasts. From the succulent crab cakes to the buttery lobster, each bite is a tantalizing explosion of flavors. Don't miss out on their signature blackened snapper - it's a showstopper! The friendly staff and breathtaking views make Atlantic's Edge the perfect spot to indulge in the best seafood in Islamorada.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in South Lake Tahoe.

Tides Beachside Bar & Grill

Tides Beachside Bar & Grill in Islamorada is a hidden gem that oozes coastal charm. The seafood here is a whirlpool of flavors that transports you straight to the ocean. Don't miss their succulent lobster rolls and crispy calamari. With its beachfront views and scrumptious seafood, Tides is a seafood lover's paradise.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Fort Lauderdale.

Islamorada Fish Company

Oh, Islamorada Fish Company, you delicious gem in the heart of Islamorada! Your seafood delights left me with a euphoric taste bud dance! The freshness of your catch is evident in every succulent bite. The playful ambiance and attentive service only added to the charm. It's no wonder you're considered one of the best seafood spots in Islamorada!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in South Jersey.

Islamorada Shrimp Shack

The moment I stepped foot into the Islamorada Shrimp Shack, I knew I was in for a treat. With its playful seaside decor and a mouthwatering aroma that tickled my taste buds, this place had all the ingredients for a memorable seafood feast.

I was greeted by a friendly staff who eagerly recommended their signature dishes. I couldn't resist trying their succulent peel-and-eat shrimp, which were seasoned to perfection and had just the right amount of kick. Each bite was a burst of freshness that transported me straight to the ocean.

But wait, there's more! The fish tacos were a revelation. Tender and flaky fish nestled in warm tortillas, topped with a zesty salsa and a hint of tangy lime. It was a party in my mouth, and I was the guest of honor.

To top it all off, the Islamorada Shrimp Shack boasted stunning views of the shimmering sea. I couldn't help but enjoy my meal while basking in the warm sun and breathing in the salty breeze.

If you find yourself in Islamorada and craving the best seafood experience, look no further than the Islamorada Shrimp Shack. It's a playful and professional haven of seafood delights that will leave your taste buds singing and your heart yearning for more.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Staten Island.

Wahoo's Seafood Bar and Grill Restaurant

I must say, Wahoo's Seafood Bar and Grill Restaurant in Islamorada left me feeling like I had discovered a hidden treasure. The menu boasted an array of delectable seafood options that made it difficult to choose just one. From their succulent lobster tails to their crispy coconut shrimp, each dish was bursting with flavors that danced on my taste buds. The freshness of the seafood was evident in every bite, and the staff's knowledge of the menu was both reassuring and helpful. The lively atmosphere added to the already delightful experience, making it a place I would happily visit again. Wahoo's is a true gem among the seafood restaurants in Islamorada, and it comes highly recommended for those seeking a delightful dining experience.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Southern Maine.

ReelCatch Restaurant

ReelCatch Restaurant in Islamorada is a seafood lover's paradise! The playful atmosphere combined with the professional service made it a standout experience. The bold flavors of their fresh catches left my taste buds dancing in excitement. If you're looking for the best seafood in Islamorada, look no further than ReelCatch!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Southport NC.

Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar

Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar in Islamorada is a hidden gem for seafood lovers like me. The playful atmosphere, combined with their superb seafood dishes, creates a dining experience that is simply divine. From their succulent lobster to their perfectly grilled fish, every bite is a tantalizing taste of the sea. Don't miss the opportunity to enjoy their fresh catches while sipping on a cocktail under the swaying palm trees. Trust me, this place is an absolute must-visit for seafood enthusiasts in Islamorada.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Howth Ireland.

Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet

Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet in Islamorada is a seafood lover's paradise. The buffet offers an extensive selection of mouthwatering dishes, from succulent shrimp to expertly prepared fish. The seafood is always fresh, and the atmosphere is relaxed and fun. With its affordable prices and generous portions, Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet is definitely a must-visit seafood spot in Islamorada!

You might also want to check out the best seafood market in Fort Lauderdale.

Hungry Tarpon Restaurant

After hearing so much buzz about the seafood at Hungry Tarpon Restaurant in Islamorada, I decided to check it out for myself. Boy, was I in for a treat! The menu was teeming with a mouthwatering selection of fresh catches, from succulent shrimp to flaky fish. Each bite was an explosion of flavor, leaving me hooked and wanting more. The service was impeccable, with knowledgeable staff who made helpful recommendations. It's safe to say that Hungry Tarpon has certainly earned its spot as one of the best seafood spots in Islamorada.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Southern California.