Key West Duval Street's Best Seafood [Updated 2024]

Having reviewed a total of 12 exceptional seafood restaurants, I have carefully curated a list of the absolute finest establishments in Duval Street, Key West. Whether you are a seafood aficionado or a casual diner, this guide is tailored to suit all palates.

Delve into the depths of Key West's culinary scene and discover the unparalleled flavors that await you at these outstanding seafood restaurants. From succulent crab cakes to mouthwatering lobster bisque, prepare your taste buds for a sensational journey.

Get ready to savor the very best seafood that Duval Street has to offer.

Pinchers

Highlights
Good seafood
Delicious crab legs
Great service
Busy atmosphere
Recommended experience

From the moment I stepped inside Pinchers, I knew I was in for a treat. The aroma of fresh seafood wafted through the air, instantly making my mouth water. The atmosphere was lively and bustling with excited chatter and clinking of glasses. It was the perfect place to dive into some mouthwatering seafood.

As I eagerly scanned the menu, my eyes were immediately drawn to the delicious crab legs. How could I resist? I ordered a platter and waited patiently for it to arrive. And let me tell you, it was well worth the wait.

The crab legs were cooked to perfection - tender and succulent, with just the right amount of seasoning. Each bite was a burst of flavor, and I savored every moment. The quality of the seafood was simply outstanding.

But what truly impressed me was the excellent service. The staff went above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. They were attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable, offering recommendations and answering any questions I had. Their warm hospitality added an extra touch to the already delightful meal.

Pinchers is undoubtedly a popular spot, and it was evident from the busy atmosphere. Despite the crowds, the waitstaff remained efficient and attentive, making sure every guest felt taken care of.

After this wonderful experience, I can confidently say that Pinchers on Key West Duval Street is a must-visit for seafood lovers. The combination of good seafood, delicious crab legs, great service, and lively atmosphere creates a truly memorable dining experience. Whether you're a local or a tourist, I highly recommend adding Pinchers to your Key West itinerary.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Myrtle Beach.

Mangoes Restaurant

Highlights
Quality of food
Fresh fish
Good vegetarian options
Friendly staff
Quick service

Let me just start by saying, WOW! Mangoes Restaurant in Key West Duval Street has truly left a lasting impression on me. From the moment I walked in, I could feel the lively energy and vibrant atmosphere. As I perused the menu, I was thrilled to see an array of seafood options that catered to both traditionalists like myself and even those seeking something a bit more unique.

Let's talk about the quality of food. Each dish at Mangoes is a masterpiece. The flavors are balanced, the presentation is impeccable, and the taste? Well, it's nothing short of extraordinary. The fresh fish is undoubtedly the star of the show, with each bite delivering a burst of freshness and a melt-in-your-mouth sensation. The chefs at Mangoes truly know how to bring out the best in their seafood.

Now, as someone who occasionally enjoys a break from seafood, I was delighted to find out that Mangoes also offers a variety of good vegetarian options. It's truly a seafood lover's paradise, but they haven't forgotten about those who prefer a meatless meal.

What truly sets Mangoes apart, besides the outstanding food, is the friendly staff. From the moment I sat down, I felt welcomed and taken care of. The attentive and knowledgeable waitstaff were more than happy to offer their recommendations and answer any questions I had. Their charisma and warmth only enhanced the overall experience.

Lastly, I must mention the quick service. Despite the restaurant being quite busy, my food arrived promptly, which is always a plus when you're hungry and craving some delectable seafood.

Overall, Mangoes Restaurant in Key West Duval Street is a seafood lover's paradise. With its exceptional quality of food, selection of fresh fish, good vegetarian options, and friendly and efficient staff, it's no wonder this gem shines brightly among the sea of seafood restaurants.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in New Orleans.

Stinkin Crawfish Key West

Highlights
Amazing seafood
Mouthwatering sauces
Fresh and delicious dishes
Great drinks
Yummy Key Lime pie

From the moment I walked into Stinkin Crawfish, I knew I was in for a treat. The aroma of amazing seafood wafted through the air, instantly making my mouth water in anticipation. The menu boasted an impressive selection of dishes, showcasing the freshest catches of the day.

One of the highlights of my visit was the variety of mouthwatering sauces available. Each sauce had its own unique blend of flavors that perfectly complemented the seafood. Whether you prefer a tangy citrus kick or a spicy Cajun heat, Stinkin Crawfish has a sauce to satisfy every palate.

The dishes themselves were nothing short of perfection. Each bite was a burst of flavor, with the seafood being the star of the show. It's clear that the chefs at Stinkin Crawfish take pride in using only the highest quality ingredients to create their fresh and delicious dishes.

To accompany my meal, I indulged in one of their great drinks. From tropical cocktails to ice-cold beers, their drink menu was just as impressive as their food. Sipping on a refreshing beverage while enjoying my seafood feast was the perfect way to unwind and soak in the lively atmosphere of Key West Duval Street.

And of course, no visit to Stinkin Crawfish would be complete without trying their yummy Key Lime pie. It was the perfect balance of tangy and sweet, with a buttery graham cracker crust that melted in my mouth.

Overall, Stinkin Crawfish exceeded my expectations and left me craving for more. It's no wonder why it's considered one of the best seafood spots on Key West Duval Street. If you're looking for a delightful seafood experience with a playful twist, Stinkin Crawfish is a must-visit.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Houston.

Sunset Pier

Sunset Pier in Key West Duval Street is a seafood paradise! The crab cakes were divine, the lobster was succulent, and the shrimp cocktail was a mouthwatering delight. The atmosphere was captivating, with the sunset providing the perfect backdrop. A must-visit for seafood enthusiasts on Duval Street.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Charleston SC.

Blackfin Bistro

Blackfin Bistro is a hidden gem on Key West Duval Street. With its elegant ambience and flawlessly cooked seafood, it truly stands out among the rest. The exquisite flavors of their dishes will make your taste buds dance with joy. Don't miss this seafood haven!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Galveston.

Conch Republic Seafood Company

Conch Republic Seafood Company in Key West Duval Street is a playful, yet professional spot to indulge in the best seafood. Their menu boasts an impressive array of fresh delights, from succulent shrimp to mouth-watering lobster. With their unbeatable waterfront location, it's a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Atlanta.

Willie T's

Willie T's in Key West Duval Street is a hidden gem for seafood lovers! The lively atmosphere and extensive menu make it a must-visit. The fresh and succulent seafood options, from lobster to shrimp, will satisfy even the pickiest palate. Don't miss their crispy calamari - it's heavenly!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Panama City Beach.

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

I recently had the pleasure of dining at The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. on Key West Duval Street, and boy, was I hooked! From the moment I walked in, the playful yet professional atmosphere captured my attention. But it was the seafood dishes that truly stole the show. The menu boasted a bountiful selection of fresh catches that were expertly prepared and bursting with flavor. Whether you're a fan of succulent lobster, delicate shrimp, or flaky fish, The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. has got you covered. One standout dish was the creamy and indulgent lobster mac and cheese. Talk about a match made in seafood heaven! The combination of tender lobster and perfectly al dente pasta was a true feast for the senses. But let's not forget about the stellar service. The waitstaff was incredibly knowledgeable and always ready with a smile. It's clear that they take pride in providing a memorable dining experience. So if you find yourself in Key West Duval Street and craving some of the best seafood in town, make your way to The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Myrtle Beach.

Antonia's Restaurant

Antonia's Restaurant in Key West Duval Street is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. With their impeccable service and decadent seafood dishes, every bite is a taste of the ocean's delight. The freshness of their ingredients shines through in each dish, making it a must-visit spot for any seafood enthusiast in Key West Duval Street.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Dallas.

DJ's Clam Shack

DJ's Clam Shack in Key West Duval Street definitely knows how to reel in seafood lovers! Their clams are exceptionally fresh and full of briny goodness. From their succulent lobster rolls to their mouthwatering chowder, this place is a hidden gem that seafood enthusiasts must not miss.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Savannah.

Ocean Grill & Bar

With its playful yet professional atmosphere, Ocean Grill & Bar on Key West Duval Street impressed me with their seafood selection. The succulent shrimp cocktail and flavorful lobster bisque were highlights. The fresh oysters, served with a zesty mignonette, were shucked to perfection. Overall, a delightful experience for seafood enthusiasts like me.

Bagatelle

Bagatelle, located on lively Duval Street, is a seafood lover's paradise. With exquisitely fresh catches prepared with flair, this spot offers a delightful dining experience. The playful ambiance and professional staff ensure a perfect evening. Don't miss Bagatelle when uncovering the best seafood in Key West Duval Street!