Key West's Best Seafood [Updated 2024]

I have delved into the flavor-filled world of Key West's seafood scene, with a delightful task of sampling and reviewing a whopping 12 seafood establishments. From sun-soaked seafood shacks to elegant waterfront eateries, I have left no stone unturned in my quest to uncover the absolute best seafood Key West has to offer.

So, if you're craving succulent shrimp, mouthwatering crab, or a perfectly grilled fish, join me as we embark on this lighthearted and gastronomic adventure. Get ready to indulge in the finest flavors that will make your taste buds dance with delight!

Conch Republic Seafood Company

Highlights
BEST place in Key West!
Fantastic happy hour drink selection
Incredible food
Vegetarian options available
Kid-friendly atmosphere

Conch Republic Seafood Company is the best place to indulge in seafood in Key West. As soon as I stepped into the restaurant, I could feel a vibrant and lively atmosphere. The fantastic happy hour drink selection caught my eye immediately, and I couldn't resist trying their signature Key Lime Martini. It was tangy and refreshing, a perfect complement to the sunny Florida weather.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the food. The menu at Conch Republic Seafood Company offers an incredible array of seafood dishes. From freshly shucked oysters to succulent lobster tails, every bite was a taste of oceanic bliss. Their seafood is sourced locally, ensuring freshness and supporting the local economy.

What impressed me the most was that Conch Republic Seafood Company also caters to vegetarian patrons. They have a variety of vegetarian options, including a flavorful vegetable paella and a delectable cauliflower steak. It's truly a haven for all seafood lovers, regardless of dietary preferences.

As I savored each bite, I couldn't help but notice the kid-friendly atmosphere. Families were enjoying their meals, and the staff made everyone feel welcome and accommodated.

Conch Republic Seafood Company truly lives up to its reputation as the best seafood spot in Key West. I highly recommend visiting for an unforgettable seafood dining experience that is both playful and professional.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in South Jersey.

Pinchers

Highlights
Delicious crab legs
Great service
Busy atmosphere
Best seafood experience in Key West
Kid-friendly place

Let me start by saying that Pinchers truly provides an unforgettable seafood experience in Key West. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a vibrant and busy atmosphere filled with the aroma of delectable seafood dishes.

One highlight of my visit was their delicious crab legs. The meat was succulent and flavorful, cooked to perfection. Pair that with their shrimp cocktail, and you have a perfect seafood feast. The freshness and quality of the seafood were evident in every bite.

Aside from the fantastic food, the service at Pinchers was top-notch. The staff was friendly, efficient, and always ready to offer recommendations from their extensive menu. Their attention to detail ensured that my dining experience was nothing short of exceptional.

What's more, Pinchers is a kid-friendly place, making it a great choice for families. The vibrant atmosphere and variety of options on the menu are sure to please even the pickiest little eaters.

Overall, Pinchers is without a doubt a standout in Key West when it comes to seafood. With their delicious crab legs, friendly service, and bustling atmosphere, it's no wonder why Pinchers is consistently considered one of the best seafood spots in town. So if you're in the mood for a memorable seafood feast, make sure to give Pinchers a try!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Southern Maine.

Eaton Street Seafood Market

Highlights
Fresh seafood
Tasty lobster roll
Crab cake sandwich
Outdoor seating
Fast service

When it comes to finding the best seafood in Key West, Eaton Street Seafood Market definitely stands out. From the moment I stepped inside, I could immediately sense the freshness in the air. The market boasts a wide variety of seafood options, catering to every seafood lover's cravings.

One standout dish that caught my attention was their mouthwatering lobster roll. The tender and succulent lobster meat was delicately tossed in a creamy dressing and nestled in a perfectly toasted buttery bun. Each bite was a heavenly blend of flavors that left me craving for more.

Another must-try item on their menu is their crab cake sandwich. The perfectly seasoned crab cake was generously stacked between two soft buns and topped with tangy remoulade sauce. It was a true seafood delight that satisfied both my taste buds and my craving for a great sandwich.

What truly sets Eaton Street Seafood Market apart is their commitment to creating a pleasant dining experience. They offer inviting outdoor seating, allowing you to enjoy your meal amidst the vibrant atmosphere of Key West. The service was also a standout feature, with their attentive and fast staff ensuring that every guest was well taken care of.

If you're on the hunt for the best seafood in Key West, look no further than Eaton Street Seafood Market. With their fresh, flavorful dishes, delightful outdoor seating, and top-notch service, this place is a seafood lover's haven. Don't miss the chance to indulge in their delightful lobster roll and crab cake sandwich – you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Keywest.

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

Highlights
Hidden gem
Grilled shrimp app
Special: lobster, filet, blue cheese
Interesting menu
Thai red chili curried black grouper

Walking into The Flaming Buoy Filet Co., I felt like I had discovered a hidden gem in Key West. This charming restaurant had a warm and inviting atmosphere, and the staff greeted me with a friendly smile.

The menu at The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. was certainly intriguing. I started my meal with their grilled shrimp appetizer that was simply divine. The shrimp were perfectly cooked and had a smoky flavor that was enhanced by a tangy sauce. It was a great start to my seafood adventure.

For my main course, I couldn't resist trying their special for the day – a mouthwatering combination of lobster, filet, and blue cheese. The flavors melded together in a delightful symphony of richness and decadence. Each bite was like a little slice of seafood heaven.

What sets The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. apart from other seafood restaurants in Key West is their commitment to offering unique and interesting dishes. One item that caught my eye was their Thai red chili curried black grouper. I must say, it was a bold and adventurous choice for my taste buds. The fusion of Thai flavors with the fresh black grouper was a culinary masterpiece.

Overall, my experience at The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. was delightful. The combination of delicious seafood, interesting menu options, and friendly service made for a memorable dining experience. If you're in Key West and looking for top-notch seafood in a cozy atmosphere, this is definitely the place to go.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Key West.

Two Friends Patio Restaurant

Highlights
Laid-back Key West experience
Great food, prices, and portions
Happy Hour specials
Live Blues musician
Wheelchair accessible

Let me start by saying that Two Friends Patio Restaurant offers a laid-back Key West experience that instantly puts you in the mood for some delicious seafood. As soon as I walked in, the lively atmosphere and friendly staff welcomed me.

The first thing that caught my attention was the menu, which features a wide variety of seafood options. From classic dishes like crab cakes and lobster bisque to innovative creations like coconut shrimp tacos, there is something for every seafood lover here.

Not only is the food at Two Friends Patio Restaurant absolutely mouthwatering, but the prices and portions are also very reasonable. You definitely get great value for your money without compromising on taste or quality.

To make things even better, they have Happy Hour specials that are hard to resist. Sipping on a refreshing cocktail while enjoying a flavorful plate of key lime shrimp skewers was the ultimate treat.

But it's not just about the food and drinks at Two Friends Patio Restaurant. The lively atmosphere is enhanced by a live Blues musician, providing the perfect soundtrack to your seafood feast.

Another standout aspect of this seafood restaurant is that it is wheelchair accessible, ensuring that everyone can enjoy the delightful culinary experience on offer.

In conclusion, Two Friends Patio Restaurant is a delightful spot that combines great food, friendly service, and a lively Key West vibe. If you're looking for the best seafood in town, this place should be at the top of your list.

You might also want to check out the best cheap seafood in Key West.

"Off The Hook" Grill

Highlights
Friendly staff
Delicious food
Unique dishes
Great desserts
Upscale cocktails

From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a friendly staff that made me feel right at home. They were knowledgeable about the menu and happily answered all of my questions.

Now, let's talk about the delicious food. It was truly a feast for the senses. Every bite was bursting with flavor, and the seafood was so fresh, it practically swam onto my plate. The chef's creativity shines through in each dish, with unique combinations that I haven't seen elsewhere. From the coconut crusted shrimp to the Key West fish tacos, each item on the menu was a culinary delight.

And let's not forget about the great desserts. I indulged in their key lime pie, and it was the perfect balance of tangy and sweet. It was like a taste of the tropics in every bite.

To wash it all down, "Off The Hook" Grill has an impressive selection of upscale cocktails. The mixologists really know their stuff, and their drinks are expertly crafted. Whether you prefer a classic mojito or a fruity frozen concoction, they have something to please every palate.

In conclusion, "Off The Hook" Grill is a seafood lover's paradise. The combination of friendly service, delicious food, unique dishes, great desserts, and upscale cocktails create an experience that is truly off the hook. I highly recommend giving it a try if you're looking for the best seafood in Key West.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Boston.

Stinkin Crawfish Key West

Highlights
Amazing seafood
Perfect overall feel
Great service
Butter shrimp

From the moment I stepped into Stinkin Crawfish Key West, I knew I was in for a treat. The place had the perfect overall feel, with its lively atmosphere and friendly staff. The aroma of amazing seafood filled the air, making my mouth water in anticipation.

I started off with their infamous butter shrimp, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The shrimp were cooked to perfection, with a rich and flavorful butter sauce that had me practically licking my fingers. Each bite was a burst of delectable goodness that left me wanting more.

What impressed me the most about Stinkin Crawfish Key West was the outstanding service. The staff was attentive and knowledgeable, always ready to cater to any request or answer any question. They made me feel welcomed and valued as a customer, enhancing my dining experience to the fullest.

Overall, Stinkin Crawfish Key West truly lives up to its name as one of the best seafood spots in Key West. From the mouthwatering butter shrimp to the perfect ambiance, everything about this place screams excellence. If you're a seafood lover looking for an unforgettable dining experience, Stinkin Crawfish Key West is a must-visit.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Baltimore.

Turtle Kraals

Highlights
Vibrant atmosphere
Wide array of dishes
Fresh seafood and Caribbean specialties
Attentive staff
Memorable island dining experience

Turtle Kraals is a true gem when it comes to finding the best seafood in Key West. As soon as I stepped into this vibrant establishment, I knew I was in for a memorable island dining experience.

The atmosphere at Turtle Kraals is nothing short of lively. With its open-air setting and stunning views of the marina, you can't help but feel the island vibes. The vibrant colors and energetic music create a truly delightful ambiance that complements the delicious food perfectly.

Speaking of food, the menu at Turtle Kraals offers a wide array of dishes that will satisfy any seafood lover's cravings. From the fresh catch of the day to Caribbean specialties like conch fritters, there's something for everyone here. Each dish is crafted with care and showcases the freshness of the seafood.

Not only is the food outstanding, but the staff at Turtle Kraals is also incredibly attentive. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warmth and made to feel like a valued guest. The servers were knowledgeable about the menu and provided excellent recommendations.

Overall, Turtle Kraals is a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts in Key West. The vibrant atmosphere, wide array of dishes, and fresh seafood make it a standout choice. The attentive staff adds an extra touch of hospitality that elevates the dining experience. Whether you're a local or a visitor, don't miss out on the opportunity to enjoy top-notch seafood at Turtle Kraals.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Ocean City MD.

A&B Lobster House

Highlights
Romantic ambiance
Excellent food
Outstanding service
Beautiful harbor view

Let me tell you, the moment I stepped foot into A&B Lobster House, I was immediately captivated by its romantic ambiance. The cozy, candlelit tables and the soft sounds of live piano music created an atmosphere that was perfect for a special night out.

Now, let's talk about the food. Oh my taste buds, where do I even begin? The menu at A&B Lobster House boasts an array of seafood delicacies, and each dish was an absolute delight. From the succulent lobster bisque to the perfectly grilled snapper, every bite was a burst of flavor that left me longing for more. The excellent food truly exceeded my expectations.

But what truly stood out to me was the outstanding service provided by the staff. Their attentiveness and knowledge of the menu made me feel like a VIP throughout my entire dining experience. They were prompt, professional, and always had a friendly smile on their faces. It's clear that the staff at A&B Lobster House goes above and beyond to ensure that their guests feel welcomed and well taken care of.

To top it all off, the restaurant offers a breathtaking view of the beautiful harbor. As I savored my meal, I couldn't help but be mesmerized by the glistening waters and the gentle sway of the boats. It added a touch of tranquility to an already perfect evening.

In conclusion, A&B Lobster House truly lives up to its reputation as one of the best seafood restaurants in Key West. From the romantic ambiance and excellent food to the outstanding service and stunning harbor view, this place is a seafood lover's dream come true. So, if you find yourself in Key West, don't miss the chance to indulge in the culinary delights of A&B Lobster House. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Portsmouth NH.

Half Shell Raw Bar

Highlights
Excellent service
Delicious seafood
Cool decorations
Key lime pie
Great happy hour

From the moment I stepped into Half Shell Raw Bar, I was greeted with a warm smile and excellent service. The staff was attentive, knowledgeable, and made me feel right at home.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show: the seafood. Oh, boy! The seafood here is simply divine. From the freshest oysters to succulent crab cakes, every bite was a burst of flavors. The chefs here truly know how to bring out the best in each dish.

The atmosphere at Half Shell Raw Bar is another highlight. The walls are adorned with quirky and cool decorations that transport you to a laid-back coastal paradise. The place has a casual yet vibrant vibe, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a delightful seafood meal.

And let's not forget about one of the true treasures of Key West: the Key lime pie. Half Shell Raw Bar certainly knows how to do justice to this iconic dessert. The tangy-sweet combination of the creamy filling and the buttery graham cracker crust is just heavenly.

Lastly, for those seeking a great deal, Half Shell Raw Bar offers a fantastic happy hour. Sipping on their signature cocktails and enjoying discounted appetizers while taking in the lively Key West atmosphere is an experience not to be missed.

Overall, my visit to Half Shell Raw Bar was nothing short of delightful. The combination of excellent service, delicious seafood, cool decorations, mouthwatering Key lime pie, and a great happy hour makes this place a must-visit for seafood lovers in Key West.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rehoboth Beach.

B.O.'s Fish Wagon

Highlights
Fresh and delicious seafood
Great service
Quick delivery of food
Amazing conch fritters
Fresh ground meat for burgers

Picture this: you're strolling along the charming streets of Key West, the sun kissing your skin as the salty breeze fills the air. Suddenly, your nose catches a whiff of something irresistible—the tantalizing scent of fresh seafood. Your stomach grumbles with anticipation, and you follow your instincts straight to B.O.'s Fish Wagon.

From the moment I stepped foot into this seafood haven, I knew I was in for a treat. The smell of the ocean danced through the air, instantly transporting me to a world of culinary delight. The menu boasted an array of mouthwatering options, but I had my sights set on one thing: seafood.

Let me tell you, the seafood at B.O.'s Fish Wagon is a game-changer. Every bite was a medley of flavors exploding in my mouth. The fish was so fresh, you could practically taste the ocean in every morsel. Each dish was prepared with a skill and passion that could only be described as the work of culinary wizards.

But it's not just the food that stole the show. The service at B.O.'s Fish Wagon was top-notch. The staff greeted me with warm smiles and took the time to explain the menu, making sure I felt welcome and informed. Not to mention, the delivery of food was speedy and efficient, ensuring that my hunger pangs were satisfied promptly.

One standout from my visit was the conch fritters, which were simply divine. The crispy exterior gave way to a tender and flavorful center that had me going back for more. And let's not forget about the burgers—oh, the burgers! B.O.'s Fish Wagon grinds their meat fresh daily, resulting in juicy patties that are a carnivore's dream come true.

To sum it all up, B.O.'s Fish Wagon is a seafood lover's paradise. With its fresh and delicious offerings, great service, quick delivery, and those melt-in-your-mouth conch fritters, it's no wonder this hidden gem has earned its place among the best seafood spots in Key West. So, next time you find yourself in this coastal paradise, don't miss the chance to experience the magic of B.O.'s Fish Wagon—it's a seafood extravaganza you won't want to miss.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Gloucester MA.

Thirsty Mermaid

Highlights
Impressive food, staff, and wines
Wonderful ceviches and oysters Rockefeller
Amazing fish dishes and scallops
Wheelchair accessible location
Delicious green Gazpacho and yellowfin tuna

Walking into Thirsty Mermaid, oceanic vibes and a lively atmosphere instantly greeted me. This seafood gem is a must-visit for any seafood enthusiast. The first thing that caught my eye was the extensive wine list, consisting of impressive selections from around the world.

The staff at Thirsty Mermaid were not only friendly but also exceptionally knowledgeable about all things seafood. Their passion for their craft was evident, as they guided me through the menu and recommended the most delightful dishes. Speaking of which, the ceviches and oysters Rockefeller were out of this world! Each bite was an explosion of fresh flavors and perfectly balanced textures.

Moving onto the main course, the fish dishes and scallops at Thirsty Mermaid were nothing short of amazing. Cooked to perfection and accompanied by delectable sauces, they were a true feast for the taste buds.

What I found particularly impressive about Thirsty Mermaid was their commitment to accessibility. The location is wheelchair accessible, making it an inclusive destination for all seafood lovers.

And let's not forget the appetizers! The green Gazpacho and yellowfin tuna were absolutely delicious. The Gazpacho had a refreshing tanginess, while the yellowfin tuna practically melted in my mouth.

In conclusion, Thirsty Mermaid is a seafood haven in Key West. With its wonderful food, knowledgeable staff, and extensive wine selection, it is a top contender for the best seafood spot in town. Whether you're a seafood aficionado or simply looking for a memorable dining experience, Thirsty Mermaid surely won't disappoint.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Ocean City MD.