Montauk's Best Seafood [Updated 2025]

Having reviewed a total of 12 restaurants, I can confidently recommend the top establishments that truly excel in serving the freshest and most delectable seafood dishes in Montauk. From succulent lobster rolls to perfectly grilled fish, this guide will ensure that you experience the epitome of seafood greatness during your visit to this charming coastal town.

Whether you are a seafood enthusiast seeking the finest fish and shellfish or simply looking to indulge in a memorable culinary experience, Montauk's best seafood establishments will undoubtedly leave you satisfied and craving for more. So, let's dive in and explore the best seafood in Montauk!

Navy Beach Restaurant, Montauk

Highlights
Perfect wedding venue
Beautiful beachfront location
Delicious food
Excellent service
Great photo opportunities

As I set foot in Navy Beach Restaurant, I was immediately captivated by its beautiful beachfront location. It was a perfect setting that made me feel like I was dining right on the ocean's edge. The restaurant exuded a relaxed and inviting atmosphere, complemented by the sound of crashing waves and the gentle sea breeze.

The highlight of my visit to Navy Beach was undoubtedly their impeccable service. The staff greeted me with warm smiles, and their attention to detail was evident from start to finish. They took the time to ensure that my dining experience was flawless, providing excellent recommendations and catering to my every need.

Now, let's talk about the delicious food. Navy Beach truly captures the essence of Montauk by offering a menu that focuses on fresh, locally sourced seafood. From succulent lobster tails to tender seared scallops, every dish was bursting with flavor. The seafood was cooked to perfection, with each bite leaving a lasting impression on my taste buds.

If you're looking for a unique wedding venue, Navy Beach should be at the top of your list. With its picturesque location and stunning views, it provides the perfect backdrop for a truly memorable celebration. The dedicated staff goes above and beyond to ensure that every detail is taken care of, making your special day truly unforgettable.

One thing that I couldn't resist mentioning was the abundance of great photo opportunities at Navy Beach. Its breathtaking views and stylish decor make it a prime spot for capturing Instagram-worthy moments. Whether you're snapping a selfie at sunset or capturing the vibrant colors of a seafood feast, you won't be disappointed.

In conclusion, if you're seeking an exceptional seafood dining experience in Montauk, Navy Beach Restaurant is a must-visit. Its perfect blend of a beautiful beachfront location, delectable food, attentive service, and memorable ambiance make it a true gem on the Montauk dining scene.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Portsmouth NH.

Sel Rrose Montauk

Highlights
Delicious seafood
Incredible truffle fries
Fresh oysters
Amazing short rib
Excellent cocktails

From the moment I stepped into Sel Rrose Montauk, I knew I was in for a treat. The atmosphere was vibrant and lively, and the aroma of freshly cooked seafood filled the air. As I perused the menu, my taste buds tingled with anticipation.

First, let's talk about the seafood. Every dish I tried was an absolute delight. The chefs at Sel Rrose Montauk know how to prepare seafood to perfection. From the succulent lobster tail to the perfectly seared scallops, each bite was nothing short of extraordinary. The freshness of the fish was evident, and the flavors were expertly balanced.

To complement the seafood, I ordered a side of truffle fries. And oh my, they were divine. Crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, each fry was infused with the unmistakable aroma of truffle. It was a match made in culinary heaven.

Of course, no seafood experience is complete without oysters, and Sel Rrose Montauk certainly delivered. The oysters were served on a bed of crushed ice, impeccably shucked and brimming with the essence of the sea. It was a truly sensational experience.

But it wasn't just the seafood that stole the show. Sel Rrose Montauk also impressed with their amazing short rib dish. The meat was tender, melted in my mouth, and was complemented by a delectable sauce that left me craving for more.

To accompany my meal, I indulged in one of their expertly crafted cocktails. The mixologists at Sel Rrose Montauk know how to create masterpieces that perfectly complemented the flavors of the seafood. From the tangy citrus notes to the smoky undertones, each sip was a journey of taste sensations.

Overall, my visit to Sel Rrose Montauk was a seafood lover's dream come true. The combination of delicious seafood, incredible truffle fries, fresh oysters, amazing short rib, and excellent cocktails make it a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts in Montauk. Sel Rrose Montauk truly embodies the essence of seafood excellence in Montauk.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Southern Maine.

Dave's Gone Fishing

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming
Delicious and fresh
Gracious staff
Consistent excellence
Must-try Chocolate Bag

Walking into Dave's Gone Fishing, I immediately felt a warm and welcoming atmosphere, as if I had entered the cozy home of a close friend. The staff was incredibly friendly, greeting me with genuine smiles and making me feel right at home.

Now, let's talk about the seafood. Oh my goodness, it was delicious and fresh. Each bite was a burst of flavor that transported me straight to the ocean. From the perfectly grilled fish to the succulent shrimp, every dish was a true seafood lover's dream.

The staff at Dave's Gone Fishing were not only gracious, but they also knew their seafood. They were more than happy to answer any questions I had and provide recommendations based on my preferences. Their knowledge and passion for seafood were evident in every interaction.

What impressed me about Dave's Gone Fishing was their consistent excellence. Every dish I tried was executed flawlessly, leaving me wanting more. This level of consistency is a rare find in the restaurant industry and speaks volumes about the dedication of the chefs and staff.

Now, let's talk about the highlight of my visit: the Chocolate Bag. This dessert is a must-try. Picture a delicate chocolate shell filled with a divine combination of chocolate mousse, fresh berries, and whipped cream. It was a sweet masterpiece that left me in dessert heaven.

In conclusion, Dave's Gone Fishing is a gem in Montauk, offering friendly service, delicious and fresh seafood, and a dessert that will make your taste buds sing. Whether you're a seafood enthusiast or just looking for an unforgettable dining experience, this is the place to be.

You might also want to check out the best cheap seafood in Portland Maine.

Montauk Seafood Company

Montauk Seafood Company in Montauk is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. The freshness of their fish is unmatched, and the delicate flavors are a testament to their expertise. Don't miss their lobster roll - it's a divine bite of heaven. This place is truly a seafood paradise!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Boston.

Inlet Seafood Restaurant

Inlet Seafood Restaurant in Montauk is a true oceanic oasis. From the vibrant and fresh seafood to the relaxing beachfront ambiance, this place has it all. The succulent lobster* and perfectly grilled fish left me craving for more. If you're seeking the ultimate seafood experience in Montauk, set sail for Inlet Seafood Restaurant!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Baltimore.

Sammys

Sammys in Montauk is an oceanic oasis, serving up the freshest seafood you can find. From succulent lobster rolls to plump shrimp scampi, their menu is a piscatorial paradise. The friendly staff and beachy vibe make it a must-visit spot for any seafood lover in Montauk.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Ocean City MD.

Shagwong

Shagwong, oh what a delight! This quirky seafood joint in Montauk offered a playful twist on traditional seafood dishes. The lobster rolls were simply divine, bursting with sweet, succulent chunks of lobster meat. And the crispy calamari? A flavor explosion! Shagwong knows how to make seafood unforgettable.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rehoboth Beach.

MTK Lobster House

MTK Lobster House truly lives up to its name - serving divine lobster delicacies that will make your taste buds dance with delight. From their succulent lobster rolls to their buttery lobster bisque, every bite is a celebration of the ocean's finest. It's the perfect spot to indulge in Montauk's freshest catch.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Gloucester MA.

Seaside House Bar

Seaside House Bar in Montauk is a hidden gem when it comes to seafood. With its charming beachside atmosphere and a menu that showcases the freshest catch, it truly satisfies any seafood lover's cravings. From succulent lobster rolls to flavorful clam chowder, each dish is a culinary delight. Don't miss out on this seaside treasure!

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Ocean City MD.

Inlet Cafe

Inlet Cafe in Montauk is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. With its stunning waterfront views and fresh catch of the day, it's a seafood enthusiasts' paradise. From their succulent lobster rolls to their delicate scallop dishes, every bite is a flavorful adventure. Don't miss out on this seafood haven!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in New England.

Harvest on Fort Pond

Harvest on Fort Pond in Montauk is a hidden gem for seafood lovers seeking a playful yet elegant dining experience. From the divine lobster bisque to the succulent sea scallops, every dish showcases the Chef's dedication to quality. They've truly mastered the art of seafood. I highly recommend giving it a try!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rochester NY.

La Fin Kitchen & Lounge

At La Fin Kitchen & Lounge, the seafood offerings are irresistible. From the buttery lobster rolls to the succulent fish tacos, each bite is a delight. The playful yet elegant atmosphere sets the stage for a truly enjoyable dining experience. It's no wonder why this gem tops the list of the best seafood spots in Montauk.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Hyannis.