Nantucket's Best Seafood [Updated 2024]

Having personally reviewed and sampled seafood from twelve different establishments across Nantucket, I can confidently say that this article will provide you with invaluable insight into the finest seafood experiences the island has to offer. Nantucket, with its flourishing fishing industry and abundance of fresh, locally sourced ingredients, is truly a haven for seafood lovers.

From delectable lobster rolls to succulent oysters, this guide will steer you towards the most exceptional dining spots that elevate seafood to a whole new level. So, join me on this delightful culinary journey as we uncover the absolute best seafood in Nantucket.

Sayle's Seafood

Highlights
Fresh and delicious seafood
Huge portions at affordable prices
Lovely employees
Casual outdoor seating available
Must-try base scallops from Nantucket

Walking into Sayle's Seafood, I immediately knew I was in for a treat. The air was filled with the tantalizing aroma of fresh seafood that made my taste buds dance with anticipation. And boy, did Sayle's deliver!

The portions at Sayle's Seafood are nothing short of impressive. Each plate is packed to the brim with succulent seafood that could satisfy even the heartiest of appetites. And the best part? The prices are actually affordable! It's not every day that you find a seafood restaurant that offers such generous portions without breaking the bank.

But it wasn't just the food that left a lasting impression on me. The employees at Sayle's Seafood were incredibly friendly and welcoming. They made me feel like a part of their seafood-loving family, and their passion for what they do was evident in every interaction.

If you're lucky, you may even get a chance to enjoy your meal at one of their casual outdoor seating options. There's nothing quite like enjoying a plate of perfectly grilled seafood under the warm Nantucket sun.

And speaking of perfectly grilled seafood, Sayle's Seafood is known for their must-try base scallops sourced directly from Nantucket. These delicate morsels of goodness melted in my mouth, leaving me craving for more.

In conclusion, Sayle's Seafood is a hidden gem in Nantucket that you simply cannot afford to miss. From the fresh and delicious seafood to the huge portions at affordable prices, everything about this place exceeded my expectations. So, take a trip to Sayle's Seafood and let your taste buds embark on an unforgettable seafood adventure.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Boston.

The Charlie Noble

Highlights
Lobster Roll
Crab and Gouda Dip
Bone Marrow
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Outdoor Seating

The Charlie Noble, a hidden gem in the heart of Nantucket, is a maritime haven that captures the essence of the island's coastal charm. As I stepped into the restaurant, I was immediately drawn to the inviting atmosphere and nautical-inspired decor. It felt like stepping aboard an elegant ship ready to set sail on a culinary adventure.

Perusing the menu, I couldn't resist the allure of their famous Lobster Roll, a true masterpiece of succulent seafood bliss. Nestled within a buttery, toasted bun, the sweet and tender lobster meat danced harmoniously with a delicate hint of lemon. Each bite was pure ecstasy, transporting me straight to the shores of Nantucket. It was a quintessential expression of the sea's finest bounty.

The culinary journey continued with the indulgent Crab and Gouda Dip, a heavenly concoction that had me mesmerized. The rich, creamy blend of crab and smoked Gouda was a symphony of flavors that titillated my taste buds. Paired with warm, lightly toasted bread, it was the ultimate indulgence.

For the adventurous palate, The Charlie Noble also offers a unique delicacy - Bone Marrow. The rich and buttery marrow, perfectly roasted and served with crusty bread, was an unexpected delight. It showcased the restaurant's commitment to exploring new culinary horizons.

If you crave a comforting classic, indulge in their delectable Lobster Mac and Cheese. The velvety, creamy sauce enveloped generous chunks of tender lobster, creating a harmonious marriage of flavor and comfort.

To top it all off, The Charlie Noble boasts a delightful outdoor seating area, perfect for enjoying a decadent meal while basking in the island breeze. The picturesque views of the harbor added an extra touch of enchantment to the entire dining experience.

The Charlie Noble truly exemplifies the best seafood in Nantucket. With their dedication to quality ingredients and their inventive yet approachable menu, it is no surprise that they have earned their place as a top contender in the island's culinary scene. So, next time you find yourself in Nantucket, don't miss the chance to embark on a captivating seafood journey at The Charlie Noble.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Baltimore.

The Seagrille

Highlights
Fairy-tale experience
Phenomenal flavors
Larger portions
Inviting atmosphere
Variety of delicious dishes

Walking into The Seagrille felt like stepping into a fairy-tale. The cozy, yet elegant atmosphere instantly put me at ease, and I knew I was in for a special treat. As I settled into my seat, I couldn't help but notice the inviting aroma of the ocean wafting through the air.

Now, let's talk about the flavors. Oh my! The dishes at The Seagrille were nothing short of phenomenal. Each bite was a delightful explosion of freshness and creativity. From the succulent lobster tails to the perfectly seared scallops, every dish was crafted with care and precision. The chefs truly know how to bring out the best in seafood.

And speaking of portions, The Seagrille does not disappoint. The portions are generous, leaving you feeling satisfied and content. It was a refreshing change from some other restaurants where you leave feeling hungry and empty.

The variety on the menu was impressive as well. There was something for everyone, whether you prefer classic New England clam chowder or more adventurous dishes like the blackened swordfish. No matter your preference, you're sure to find a dish that tickles your taste buds.

Overall, my experience at The Seagrille was nothing short of delightful. The combination of the inviting atmosphere, phenomenal flavors, and larger portions make it a must-visit for seafood lovers in Nantucket. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Ocean City MD.

Kitty Murtagh's

Nestled in the heart of charming Nantucket, Kitty Murtagh's is a hidden gem for seafood enthusiasts. With a playful yet professional vibe, this spot offers an impressive selection of fresh and flavorful seafood dishes. From succulent lobsters to mouthwatering clam chowder, each bite was a delightful ocean adventure. Definitely a must-visit for seafood lovers!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Portsmouth NH.

Breeze Restaurant

The seafood at Breeze Restaurant in Nantucket is a game-changer! From the melt-in-your-mouth lobster bisque to the succulent sea scallops, every bite is a flavor explosion. The playful yet professional atmosphere adds a dash of fun to the dining experience. Breeze Restaurant is definitely a must-visit for seafood lovers in Nantucket!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rehoboth Beach.

Queequeg's

I had a fin-tastic time at Queequeg's in Nantucket! The seafood was delectable and the service was top-notch. From succulent lobster rolls to perfectly grilled swordfish, my taste buds were in seafood heaven. Don't miss this hidden gem on your Nantucket seafood adventure!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Gloucester MA.

B-ACK Yard BBQ

In my quest for the best seafood in Nantucket, I stumbled upon the playful yet professional paradise that is B-ACK Yard BBQ. With their fresh and flavorful seafood options, this hidden gem is a seafood lover's dream. Bold flavors, amazing service, and a cozy atmosphere make B-ACK Yard BBQ a must-visit spot.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Ocean City MD.

TOPPER'S

With its mesmerizing oceanfront view and an extensive menu that showcases the freshest catches, TOPPER'S in Nantucket is a seafood lover's dream come true. The succulent lobster rolls, seasoned to perfection, were a delightful explosion of flavors. The impeccable service and charming ambiance made the dining experience truly memorable.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in New England.

Nantucket Tap Room

I must say, Nantucket Tap Room took my taste buds on a delightful seafood adventure! The playful atmosphere combined with professional service made it a standout. The bold flavors of their seafood dishes were simply irresistible. Nantucket Tap Room is a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts in Nantucket!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rochester NY.

Brant Point Grill

Brant Point Grill in Nantucket is a seafood paradise. From the moment I stepped in, I was whisked away on a wave of delectable flavors and impeccable service. The succulent lobster, crispy calamari, and velvety clam chowder left me craving for more. Trust me, this place is a seafood lover's dream.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Hyannis.

Glidden's Island Seafood

Located in the heart of Nantucket, Glidden's Island Seafood is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. Their menu boasts a delightful array of fresh catches, from succulent lobster rolls to crispy fried clams. The flavor explosion in each bite leaves you craving for more. The friendly staff and charming coastal ambiance only enhance the dining experience. Glidden's Island Seafood is definitely a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts in Nantucket.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Plymouth MA.

The Nantucket Lobster Trap

The Nantucket Lobster Trap is a seafood haven that takes you on a flavor journey through the ocean with their impeccable selection of lobster dishes. From succulent lobster rolls to decadent lobster bisque, every bite is a delightful explosion of freshness. Oh, and let's not forget their charming nautical-themed ambiance that adds a whimsical touch to your dining experience. A must-visit for seafood enthusiasts in Nantucket!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Cape Cod.