Throughout my many years of experience in the culinary world, I have had the pleasure of indulging in the finest seafood that Siesta Key has to offer. With a total of 12 carefully reviewed establishments, I am confident in providing you with an insider's perspective on where to find the absolute best seafood in this picturesque beach town.

From mouthwatering crab cakes to succulent shrimp scampi, this guide is designed to ensure that your seafood cravings are satisfied to the fullest. So join me on this delectable journey as we dive into the flavors and experiences that make Siesta Key a seafood lover's paradise.


Big Water Fish Market

Big Water Fish Market
🗺️ 6639 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242
☎️ 941-554-8101
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–9 PM
Monday: 11 AM–9 PM
Tuesday: 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–9 PM
Friday: 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM
Highlights
Delicious seafood
Great service
Reasonable prices
Tasty sides
Hidden gem

Upon entering Big Water Fish Market, I was greeted by a welcoming and friendly staff – a refreshing change from the usual hustle and bustle of seafood joints. The smell of the delicious seafood instantly tickled my nostrils, causing my stomach to growl in anticipation.

After perusing the menu, I decided to try their famous crab cake sandwich. Let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The perfectly seasoned crab cake was nestled between a toasted bun, accompanied by a tangy tartar sauce and crisp lettuce. Each bite was a tantalizing explosion of flavors that left me craving for more.

What impressed me beyond the amazing food was the great service. The staff went out of their way to ensure my dining experience was nothing short of exceptional. They patiently answered all of my questions and made thoughtful recommendations, making me feel like a valued customer.

But here's the best part – the prices! Big Water Fish Market offers reasonable prices that won't break the bank. I left feeling satisfied, both in my belly and my wallet.

To complement the mouthwatering seafood, Big Water Fish Market provides a selection of tasty sides that are the perfect accompaniment to any meal. From crispy fries to tangy coleslaw, every side dish was as satisfying as the main course.

In a sea of seafood options in Siesta Key, Big Water Fish Market stands out as a true hidden gem. With their delicious seafood, great service, reasonable prices, and tasty sides, they have earned a spot on the list of the best seafood in Siesta Key. Don't miss out on this seafood haven – your taste buds will thank you.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Sarasota FL.

The Old Salty Dog Siesta Key

The Old Salty Dog Siesta Key
🗺️ 5023 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242
☎️ 941-349-0158
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–9 PM
Monday: 11 AM–9 PM
Tuesday: 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–9 PM
Friday: 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–9 PM
Highlights
Friendly staff
Delicious seafood
Dog-friendly
Reasonable prices

From the moment I walked through the door, I was greeted by the most friendly staff. They made me feel right at home and were more than happy to answer any questions I had about the menu.

Now, let's talk about the food. Oh, how my taste buds danced with delight with every bite of their delicious seafood! From the perfectly seasoned and tender fish to the succulent shrimp, The Old Salty Dog truly knows how to satisfy a seafood lover's cravings. The flavors were fresh, vibrant, and perfectly cooked.

What sets The Old Salty Dog apart from other seafood restaurants in Siesta Key is their inclusivity. Yes, you heard it right, they are dog-friendly! So, if you're like me and want to bring your furry friend along for a seafood feast, this is the place to be. They even have a special menu just for four-legged guests.

But wait, there's more! The prices at The Old Salty Dog are incredibly reasonable. You get top-notch quality seafood without breaking the bank. It's a win-win situation.

In conclusion, my visit to The Old Salty Dog Siesta Key was a pure delight. The friendly staff, delicious seafood, dog-friendly atmosphere, and reasonable prices make it a standout choice when it comes to the best seafood in Siesta Key. I would highly recommend giving it a try if you find yourself in the area. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Bradenton.

Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill

Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill
🗺️ 7119 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota, FL 34231
☎️ 941-413-7133
🌐 Website
Sunday: Closed
Monday: 11 AM–8 PM
Tuesday: 11 AM–8 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–8 PM
Friday: 11 AM–8 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–8 PM
Highlights
Fresh, flavorful seafood
Delicious tropical salsa
Crisp and perfectly cooked veggies
Extensive beer selection
Friendly and informative staff

Walking into Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill, I was immediately greeted by a mouth-watering aroma of fresh, flavorful seafood. I was excited to dive into their offerings and boy, was I in for a treat.

One highlight of my meal was the delicious tropical salsa served with my appetizer. Bursting with the flavors of ripe mangos, tangy pineapple, and a hint of jalapeno, it added the perfect touch of sweetness and heat to each bite.

The main course did not disappoint either. The seafood was cooked to perfection - crisp on the outside and tender on the inside. But what truly stole the show were the crisp and perfectly cooked veggies that accompanied each dish. They were cooked just right, maintaining their freshness and adding a delightful crunch to the meal.

To complement my seafood feast, I decided to explore the extensive beer selection available. The staff was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable, helping me choose the perfect brew to pair with my meal. Their recommendations were spot on, enhancing the flavors of the seafood even further.

Overall, my experience at Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill was a delightful one. The combination of fresh seafood, delicious tropical salsa, perfectly cooked veggies, and an extensive beer selection made for an unforgettable meal. The friendly and informative staff added an extra layer of enjoyment to the experience. If you're in Siesta Key and looking for the best seafood, don't miss out on Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Englewood FL.

Captain Curt's Crab & Oyster Bar - Siesta Key

Captain Curt's Crab & Oyster Bar - Siesta Key
🗺️ 1200 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242
☎️ 941-349-3885
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–10 PM
Monday: 11 AM–10 PM
Tuesday: 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–10 PM
Friday: 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM

Captain Curt's Crab & Oyster Bar - Siesta Key in Siesta Key is a playful treasure chest of delicious seafood. Their succulent crab and fresh oysters will transport your taste buds to seafood paradise. The charming atmosphere and friendly staff make it a must-visit for seafood lovers in Siesta Key.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Anna Maria Island.

Daiquiri Deck South Siesta Key

Daiquiri Deck South Siesta Key
🗺️ 1250 Stickney Point Rd, Siesta Key, FL 34242
☎️ 941-312-2422
🌐 Website
Sunday: 10 AM–10 PM
Monday: 10 AM–10 PM
Tuesday: 10 AM–10 PM
Wednesday: 10 AM–10 PM
Thursday: 10 AM–10 PM
Friday: 10 AM–11 PM
Saturday: 10 AM–11 PM

Serving up seafood with a side of tropical vibes, Daiquiri Deck South Siesta Key is a playful paradise for seafood lovers like me. The menu is a delightful blend of fresh catches and flavorful favorites, all served in a vibrant setting that screams "beach vacation." With each bite, I could taste the expertise in every dish. From succulent shrimp to perfectly grilled fish, the seafood here is a true indulgence. And let's not forget about the daiquiris – they’re dangerously delicious. So gather your friends, slip on your flip-flops, and head over to Daiquiri Deck South Siesta Key for a seafood experience that will satisfy every seafood craving.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Port Charlotte.

SPEARFISH GRILLE

SPEARFISH GRILLE
🗺️ 1265 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242
☎️ 941-349-1971
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–10 PM
Monday: 11 AM–10 PM
Tuesday: 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–10 PM
Friday: 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM

SPEARFISH GRILLE in Siesta Key is a seafood lover's paradise! With its fresh catches and tantalizing flavors, this place will hook you from the first bite. The playful yet professional ambiance adds to the delightful dining experience. Don't miss the mouthwatering lobster bisque and their divine grilled swordfish. It's a seafood feast fit for a king!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Punta Gorda.

Siesta Key Oyster Bar

Siesta Key Oyster Bar
🗺️ 5238 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242
☎️ 941-346-5443
🌐 Website
Sunday: 9 AM–11 PM
Monday: 11 AM–11 PM
Tuesday: 11 AM–11 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–11 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–11 PM
Friday: 11 AM–12 AM
Saturday: 11 AM–12 AM

My visit to the Siesta Key Oyster Bar in Siesta Key left me shucking amazed! From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a seafood treat. The lively atmosphere and friendly staff set the tone for a memorable dining experience. As a seafood aficionado, I couldn't resist trying their famous oysters, and boy, did they deliver! Each bite was a fresh burst of ocean goodness that transported me to coastal paradise. But that's not all - their menu is a seafood lover's dream, offering a tantalizing variety of dishes ranging from succulent shrimp to perfectly grilled fish. With each innovative creation, the chefs at Siesta Key Oyster Bar showcased their culinary prowess, fusing flavors and textures in ways that would make any foodie weak at the knees. The attention to detail and commitment to quality ingredients was evident in every bite. Plus, the bar was well-stocked with an impressive selection of craft beers and signature cocktails, ensuring the perfect libation to complement your seafood feast. The Siesta Key Oyster Bar truly lives up to its reputation as a seafood haven, catering to both locals and tourists alike. Whether you're craving a casual lunch or a memorable dinner, this seafood gem is a must-visit destination. So grab your bib and get ready to dive into a world of seafood delights at the Siesta Key Oyster Bar - your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Madeira Beach.

Captain Curt's Sniki Tiki Bar & Live Entertainment - Siesta Key

Captain Curt's Sniki Tiki Bar & Live Entertainment - Siesta Key
🗺️ 1204 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242
☎️ 941-349-3885
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–12 AM
Monday: 11 AM–12 AM
Tuesday: 11 AM–12 AM
Wednesday: 11 AM–12 AM
Thursday: 11 AM–12 AM
Friday: 11 AM–12 AM
Saturday: 11 AM–12 AM

Captain Curt's Sniki Tiki Bar & Live Entertainment - Siesta Key in Siesta Key is a playful yet professional establishment that perfectly combines delicious seafood with live entertainment. From their captivating atmosphere to their fresh and flavorful catches, this place oozes seaside charm. Don't miss their mouthwatering fish tacos and the crispy calamari. It's a seafood lover's paradise!

You might also want to check out the best seafood market in St Petersburg FL.

Lobster Pot Restaurant

Lobster Pot Restaurant
🗺️ 5157 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242
☎️ 941-349-2323
🌐 Website
Sunday: Closed
Monday: 11:30 AM–9 PM
Tuesday: 11:30 AM–9 PM
Wednesday: 11:30 AM–9 PM
Thursday: 11:30 AM–9 PM
Friday: 11:30 AM–9 PM
Saturday: 11:30 AM–9 PM

I must say, Lobster Pot Restaurant in Siesta Key is a seafood delight! The freshness of their lobster made my taste buds dance with joy. The buttery garlic sauce added the perfect touch to this culinary masterpiece. With friendly staff and a cozy ambience, Lobster Pot Restaurant is a must-visit for seafood lovers in Siesta Key.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Pinellas County.

The Cottage

The Cottage
🗺️ 153 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL 34242
☎️ 941-312-9300
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–10 PM
Monday: 11 AM–10 PM
Tuesday: 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–10 PM
Friday: 11 AM–11 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–11 PM

The Cottage in Siesta Key is a seafood lover's dream come true! Their menu boasts a delicious variety of fresh and flavorful seafood dishes that will transport your taste buds straight to the ocean. From the succulent lobster bisque to the crispy fried shrimp, each bite is a burst of coastal goodness. The service is top-notch too, making your dining experience truly delightful. The Cottage is definitely a must-visit spot for seafood enthusiasts in Siesta Key!

You might also want to check out the best seafood market in Tampa.

Clayton's Siesta Grille

Clayton's Siesta Grille
🗺️ 1256 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242
☎️ 941-349-2800
🌐 Website
Sunday: 4–10 PM
Monday: 4–10 PM
Tuesday: 4–10 PM
Wednesday: 4–10 PM
Thursday: 4–10 PM
Friday: 4–10:30 PM
Saturday: 4–10:30 PM

Clayton's Siesta Grille is a hidden gem that leaves taste buds dancing in gratitude. Flavors burst through every bite, with the freshest catches of the sea perfectly cooked to perfection. From succulent crab cakes to melt-in-your-mouth shrimp, their seafood extravaganza is a true celebration for your palate. Get ready to embark on a culinary adventure at Clayton's Siesta Grille!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Indian Rocks Beach.

Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood

Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood
🗺️ 149 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL 34242
☎️ 941-260-2675
🌐 Website
Sunday: 4–10 PM
Monday: 4–10 PM
Tuesday: 4–10 PM
Wednesday: 4–10 PM
Thursday: 4–10 PM
Friday: 4–11 PM
Saturday: 4–11 PM

Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood definitely impressed me with their playfully creative seafood dishes. From the buttery lobster rolls to the succulent shrimp scampi, every bite was a delight. The vibrant atmosphere, complete with live music, made for a memorable evening. Seafood lovers, this place is a hidden gem worth exploring!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Tampa.

Next Posts

Sarasota FL's Best Seafood Buffet [Updated 2024]
The Absolute Best Seafood in Bradenton  [Updated 2024]
The Absolute Best Seafood in Englewood FL  [Updated 2024]
Benjamin Marlowe

Ben is a passionate seafood enthusiast with a discerning palate and an insatiable curiosity for exploring the world's coastal culinary treasures. Born and raised on the shores of New England, Ben developed a deep appreciation for seafood from an early age, where the scent of the sea and the taste of fresh catches became an integral part of his life.