The Absolute Best Seafood Market in Brooklyn [Updated 2024]

Having reviewed a total of 12 seafood markets in Brooklyn, I can confidently say that I have found the absolute best. With my expertise and years of experience in this field, I am excited to share with you all the details of this hidden gem.

From the freshest catch to the most knowledgeable staff, this seafood market surpasses all others in the area. So whether you're a seafood enthusiast or simply looking for the highest quality ingredients for your next meal, keep reading to discover the best seafood market in Brooklyn.

Mermaid's Garden

Highlights
Fish share program
Locally caught seafood
Amazing quality fish
Curated fish and shellfish selection
Premium and hard to find pantry items

Walking into Mermaid's Garden, I was immediately struck by the charming seaside atmosphere. The rustic decor and the friendly staff made me feel like I was stepping into a hidden gem of the ocean.

One fantastic feature of Mermaid's Garden is their Fish Share Program. It allows customers to sign up for a weekly or bi-weekly selection of locally caught seafood. The variety and freshness of the fish they offer is truly impressive. From flaky cod to succulent lobsters, they have it all.

The quality of the seafood at Mermaid's Garden is absolutely amazing. You can tell that they take pride in sourcing the best fish available. Each piece is carefully selected, ensuring that customers get only the freshest catch every time.

The selection at Mermaid's Garden is not only wide, but also wonderfully curated. They offer an array of fish and shellfish, all of which are sustainably sourced. Whether you're in the mood for delicate scallops, meaty salmon, or briny oysters, they have something to satisfy every seafood lover.

In addition to their impressive seafood selection, Mermaid's Garden also offers a range of premium and hard to find pantry items. From artisanal sauces to unique seasonings, they have everything you need to elevate your seafood cooking experience.

Overall, Mermaid's Garden is a must-visit seafood market in Brooklyn. Their commitment to quality, sustainability, and customer satisfaction shines through in every aspect of their operation. So if you're looking for the freshest seafood in town, make sure to dive into Mermaid's Garden.

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Brooklyn.

Sea House Fish Market

Highlights
Large menu
Fried catfish
Steamed vegetables
Fresh fish
Great customer service

As soon as I entered Sea House Fish Market, the vibrant atmosphere caught my attention. The place was bustling with people, and the tantalizing smell of fresh seafood filled the air. The market offers a large menu with an impressive variety of options that caters to all seafood lovers.

One dish that stood out was their sumptuous fried catfish. The fish was perfectly crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. The flavorful seasoning added a delightful kick, making every bite a mouthwatering experience. Paired with a side of steamed vegetables, this dish was a true delight for both the taste buds and health-conscious individuals.

Sea House Fish Market truly lives up to its name by offering a remarkable selection of fresh fish. From salmon to snapper, the display was a feast for the eyes. The market takes pride in sourcing their seafood locally, ensuring the highest quality and supporting the community.

In addition to their delectable offerings, the customer service at Sea House Fish Market is exceptional. The staff members were both knowledgeable and friendly, willing to provide recommendations based on personal preferences. Their attention to detail and willingness to go the extra mile made the overall experience even more enjoyable.

Overall, Sea House Fish Market is a hidden gem in the heart of Brooklyn. With its diverse menu, delectable fried catfish, fresh fish options, and attentive customer service, it deserves a prominent spot in the article about the best seafood markets in Brooklyn. If you're looking for a delightful seafood experience, Sea House Fish Market is an absolute must-visit destination.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Williamsburg Brooklyn.

Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market

Highlights
Tender crab legs
Amazing sashimi-grade fish
Fresh and delicious seafood
Ultra fresh products
Excellent customer service

Let me tell you, my taste buds were dancing with joy after indulging in the seafood delights at Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market. This place truly lives up to its name, offering a treasure trove of oceanic wonders.

First of all, the crab legs were tender and burst with flavor. Each succulent bite made me feel like I was enjoying a taste of the sea itself. The sashimi-grade fish was absolutely amazing. The quality was unmatched, and every slice melted on my tongue, leaving a lingering sensation of freshness.

Speaking of freshness, the seafood at Fish Tales was as fresh as it gets. Every item displayed on ice looked so enticing that it was hard to resist purchasing everything in sight. From plump shrimp, to delicate scallops, to flaky fish fillets, it was a seafood lover's dream come true.

One thing that truly stood out was the ultra fresh products. Fish Tales takes great pride in sourcing the highest quality seafood, and it shows. The attention to detail in the selection was fantastic, ensuring that every customer can expect nothing but the best.

To top it all off, the customer service at Fish Tales was excellent. The staff was knowledgeable, friendly, and eager to assist customers in finding their ideal seafood choices. They were more than willing to share cooking tips and even offered recipe suggestions.

In conclusion, Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market is a seafood lover's heaven in the heart of Brooklyn. With tender crab legs, amazing sashimi-grade fish, and an array of fresh and delicious seafood, it's hard to find a better seafood market in town. So, if you're on the hunt for a true seafood experience, don't miss out on Fish Tales Gourmet Seafood Market. Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Brooklyn New York.

Carroll Gardens Fish Market

Carroll Gardens Fish Market in Brooklyn is a hidden gem for seafood enthusiasts. With a wide assortment of fresh and flavorful options, this market is a reel catch. The knowledgeable staff provide exceptional service and can even offer cooking tips. Don't miss out on this fin-tastic seafood market.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Boston.

Fjord Fish Market

Fjord Fish Market in Brooklyn is a seafood haven that reels you in with its marvelous selection. The playful atmosphere is perfect for the discerning seafood enthusiast. From fresh catches to expertly prepared dishes, Fjord Fish Market leaves you hooked on their delectable treasures.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Baltimore.

Pisces Fish Market

Pisces Fish Market in Brooklyn is a hidden gem of the seafood world! Their playful selection of fresh fish and professional service make every visit a delightful experience. Don't miss their succulent scallops and crave-worthy lobster rolls. Trust me, this place is a catch!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Ocean City MD.

Lucky Fish of the Sea inc.

They say luck favors the bold, and I agree because my visit to Lucky Fish of the Sea inc. was a stroke of good fortune! This seafood market in Brooklyn is a hidden gem, offering an impressive array of fresh catches from the deep blue sea. From succulent shrimp to flaky salmon fillets, their selection is top-notch. The friendly staff had me hooked with their knowledge and charisma, making my shopping experience a true delight. Whether you're a seasoned seafood lover or a curious newbie, make your way to Lucky Fish of the Sea inc. for a reel-y great time!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Portsmouth NH.

Rosenfeld's Fish Market

Hey there seafood lovers! As a self-proclaimed connoisseur of all things fishy, I recently made my way to Brooklyn to embark on a seafood adventure at Rosenfeld's Fish Market. Brace yourselves, because this place is a delight for both the eyes and taste buds. From the moment I stepped inside, I knew I was in for a treat. The vibrant colors of the freshly caught treasures on display were enough to make any seafood aficionado's heart skip a beat. And let me tell you, the flavors did not disappoint. Each bite felt like a symphony of oceanic bliss, transporting me to the coastal wonderlands of my dreams. Whether you're a seasoned sea creature enthusiast or just dipping your toes into the oceanic world of seafood, Rosenfeld's Fish Market is an absolute must-visit. Trust me when I say that you won't find a more fin-tastic seafood haven in all of Brooklyn!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rehoboth Beach.

E & C Fish Market & Seafood

E & C Fish Market & Seafood in Brooklyn is an absolute catch! With a wide variety of fresh seafood options, it's a seafood lover's paradise. The friendly staff and their impressive knowledge ensure you'll find the perfect fish for any dish. Don't miss out on this hidden gem in Brooklyn!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Gloucester MA.

Duncan's Fish Market

Duncan's Fish Market in Brooklyn is a hidden seafood gem that won my heart with their fresh catches and charming atmosphere. The staff's knowledge and friendly banter made shopping a joy. From succulent shrimp to melt-in-your-mouth salmon, Duncan's is a seafood lover's paradise. Don't miss this delightful market!

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Ocean City MD.

Sun Fresh Fish Market

Sun Fresh Fish Market in Brooklyn is a seafood haven that will make your taste buds sing with joy. From glistening shrimp to succulent salmon, they offer a truly fresh and diverse selection. The knowledgeable staff provide stellar service, turning your visit into an unforgettable seafood adventure.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in New England.

Andrew Lee's Fish Market

Andrew Lee's Fish Market in Brooklyn is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. With its playful yet professional atmosphere, you'll find an array of fresh catches that will make your taste buds dance. The expertise of the staff is impressive, and their commitment to quality is unmatched. Don't miss out on their delicious specials—I guarantee you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Rochester NY.