Key West's Best Seafood Buffet [Updated 2024]

With my extensive knowledge and expertise in seafood buffets, I have personally reviewed a total of 12 outstanding options in Key West. After meticulous research and countless mouthwatering culinary experiences, I can confidently declare that I have found the crème de la crème of seafood buffets in this vibrant Florida city.

This article will navigate you through the highlights, providing you with an in-depth analysis of the top choices. Get ready to indulge in the freshest catches, exquisitely prepared dishes, and a dining experience that is sure to satisfy even the most discerning seafood connoisseurs.

So, let's dive in and explore the best seafood buffet that Key West has to offer!

Palm Haven Restaurant

Highlights
Great service
Nice food
Welcoming

Let me start by saying that Palm Haven Restaurant has definitely secured a spot on the list of the best seafood buffets in Key West. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm and friendly welcome, which immediately set the tone for the whole experience.

One of the highlights of my visit was the impeccable service. The staff at Palm Haven Restaurant were attentive, knowledgeable, and always ready to provide assistance. They went above and beyond to ensure that my dining experience was nothing short of exceptional.

Now, let's talk about the food. The spread at Palm Haven was nothing short of impressive. The wide variety of seafood options available was truly a seafood lover's dream come true. From succulent crab legs to tender shrimp, there was something to satisfy every palate. The freshness and quality of the ingredients were evident in each bite, and the flavors were well-balanced and delicious.

The ambience of the restaurant was pleasant and inviting. The cozy and relaxed atmosphere added to the overall dining experience. Whether you're going for a casual lunch or a special dinner, Palm Haven Restaurant is a great choice for any occasion.

In conclusion, Palm Haven Restaurant exceeds expectations and leaves a lasting impression. With its great service, delicious food, and welcoming atmosphere, it is definitely a top contender for the title of the best seafood buffet in Key West. Don't miss out on the opportunity to indulge in a feast fit for a seafood enthusiast.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Key West Duval Street.

The Stoned Crab

Highlights
Open air seating
Wonderful service
Amazing lunch
Best seafood
Perfectly cooked
Added experience

This seafood buffet at The Stoned Crab is truly a hidden gem in Key West. As I arrived, I was immediately drawn to the open air seating, which provided a refreshing setting for my meal. The staff greeted me with genuine warmth and their wonderful service set the tone for a delightful dining experience.

As soon as I made my way to the buffet, I couldn't help but notice the amazing lunch spread before me. A wide variety of seafood dishes beckoned, from succulent crab legs to perfectly grilled shrimp. The selection was truly impressive and left me spoilt for choice.

But what truly sets The Stoned Crab apart from other seafood buffets is the quality of their food. Every bite was bursting with flavor, showcasing the very best seafood the Key West has to offer. The perfectly cooked fish melted in my mouth, while the lobster bisque had a rich and velvety texture that delighted my taste buds.

Not only was the food exceptional, but dining at The Stoned Crab was also an added experience. With its casual yet elegant atmosphere, I felt completely relaxed as I indulged in my seafood feast.

If you're looking for the best seafood buffet in Key West, look no further than The Stoned Crab. Trust me, you won't be disappointed with their wonderful service, amazing lunch, and the incredible freshness of their seafood. It's an experience you won't want to miss.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Keywest.

Conch Republic Seafood Company

Highlights
Friendly staff
Beautiful location
Delicious food
Great Bloody Mary
Perfectly cooked conch fritters

From the moment I walked into Conch Republic Seafood Company, I was greeted by the friendly staff who immediately made me feel at home. The restaurant itself is situated in a beautiful location, offering picturesque views of the ocean.

Now let's talk about the main attraction - the seafood buffet. Oh boy, the food was delicious. The buffet offered a wide variety of fresh seafood options, from succulent shrimp to mouthwatering crab legs. Each dish was expertly prepared and seasoned to perfection. My absolute favorite, however, were the conch fritters, which were cooked perfectly and had just the right amount of crunch.

To accompany my meal, I ordered a Bloody Mary, and boy, was it a game-changer. The Conch Republic Seafood Company definitely knows how to mix a great Bloody Mary. It was the perfect blend of flavors with just the right amount of kick.

Overall, my experience at Conch Republic Seafood Company was top-notch. The combination of friendly staff, beautiful location, and top-quality seafood made it a standout among the seafood buffets in Key West. If you're a seafood lover like me, be sure not to miss out on this gem. It truly deserves a spot in the conversation about the best seafood buffet in Key West.

You might also want to check out the best cheap seafood in Key West.

Pinchers

Pinchers in Key West: I recently had the pleasure of dining at Pinchers in Key West and it was an absolute seafood extravaganza! From the captivating aroma to the tantalizing array of seafood delicacies, my taste buds danced with joy. The freshly caught shrimp and succulent crab legs stole the show, but the scrumptious oysters and flaky fish were not to be ignored either. The friendly and attentive staff made my dining experience even more delightful. If you're a seafood lover looking for a buffet that will make you sing with glee, Pinchers is the place to be!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Key West.

Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar

Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar in Key West is a seafood buffet that will delight your taste buds and leave you craving for more. The playful ambiance sets the stage for a delectable feast of fresh seafood. From succulent shrimp to mouthwatering oysters, their buffet spreads like a culinary masterpiece. Don't miss out on this seafood extravaganza!

You might also want to check out the best seafood market in Marathon FL.

Eaton Street Seafood Market

Hey there seafood lovers! I recently had the opportunity to dive into the seafood wonders at Eaton Street Seafood Market in beautiful Key West. Let me tell you, they're reeling in some serious flavor! From succulent crab legs to buttery lobster tails, this place is a treasure trove of mouthwatering seafood delights. So grab your bib and prepare to feast like a king!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Marathon FL.

Stinkin Crawfish Key West

Stinkin Crawfish Key West is a hidden gem in Key West's seafood buffet scene. Their playfully named establishment offers a vibrant and lively atmosphere that perfectly complements their delectable spread of seafood delights. From succulent crawfish to mouthwatering crab legs, their menu is an oceanic adventure for your taste buds. Don't forget to save room for their sinfully irresistible lobster bisque! This place clearly deserves a spot on the list of the best seafood buffets in Key West.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Islamorada.

Ocean Grill & Bar

Ocean Grill & Bar in Key West surprised me with its amazing selection of seafood dishes. The buffet spread was impressive, featuring fresh oysters, succulent crab legs, and perfectly cooked shrimp. The vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff added to the overall enjoyable dining experience. I highly recommend it for seafood lovers looking for a memorable buffet experience in Key West.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Key Largo.

Paradise seafood key west

Paradise Seafood Key West is a playful and delicious seafood buffet in the heart of Key West. The vibrant atmosphere and fresh seafood options make it a top contender for the title of best seafood buffet in town. From succulent shrimp to melt-in-your-mouth crab legs, this place has it all. Don't forget to save room for their heavenly key lime pie!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Naples Florida.

Yummy Crab

I'm thrilled to add a review of Yummy Crab to my quest for the best seafood buffet in Key West! The lively atmosphere and fresh seafood selection make this place a must-try for seafood enthusiasts. The flavorful crab legs and succulent lobster were the absolute highlights. A definite contender for the top spot!

You might also want to check out the best seafood market in Naples Florida.

Bagatelle

Bagatelle in Key West is a hidden gem for seafood enthusiasts. Their playful and professional atmosphere made my experience here unforgettable. The endless selection of fresh and flavorful seafood options left me in awe. This hidden treasure truly deserves a spot on the list of the best seafood buffets in Key West.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Kendall.

DJ's Clam Shack

DJ's Clam Shack in Key West is a seafood lover's paradise! The buffet spread is a glorious feast of freshly caught treasures from the sea. Crab legs so succulent they practically dance on your taste buds, shrimp so plump and juicy they're like little bites of heaven—it's sheer seafood bliss! The friendly staff and lively atmosphere only add to the dining experience. Don't miss out on the crab cakes—they're to die for! DJ's Clam Shack is definitely a key player in the quest for the best seafood buffet in Key West.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Bonita Springs.