Pawleys Island's Best Seafood [Updated 2024]

Having reviewed a total of 12 seafood restaurants in Pawleys Island, I can confidently say that I have uncovered the true gems of this coastal paradise. From succulent oysters to perfectly grilled fish, this article is your go-to resource for discovering the finest seafood establishments in town.

With a focus on excellence, I have meticulously evaluated each restaurant, taking into account not only the quality of the dishes but also the ambiance, service, and overall dining experience. So if you're a seafood enthusiast in search of the best culinary delights in Pawleys Island, look no further.

Let's dive into this tantalizing journey together!

Pawleys Island Tavern

Highlights
Great burgers
Hughe portions
Reasonable prices
Good service
Unique atmosphere

As soon as I walked into Pawleys Island Tavern, I was immediately struck by the unique atmosphere of the place. With its rustic wooden decor and charming coastal accents, it truly captured the essence of Pawleys Island. But what intrigued me the most was its reputation for delicious seafood, which is exactly what I was there to discover.

While their seafood offerings were limited, the menu had other options that caught my attention. I decided to try one of their renowned burgers. And boy, was I not disappointed! The burger was juicy and perfectly cooked, accompanied by a generous portion of crispy fries. The flavors were exceptional and satisfied my cravings.

What impressed me most about Pawleys Island Tavern was the huge portions they served. It was clear that they wanted to ensure their customers would never go hungry. Despite the generous portions, the reasonable prices were certainly a pleasant surprise. It's not often that you can enjoy a satisfying meal without breaking the bank!

The good service I received throughout my visit was also worth mentioning. The staff was friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about their menu. They were quick to accommodate my requests and offered helpful recommendations.

Overall, my experience at Pawleys Island Tavern was delightful. While it may not be a seafood-centric restaurant, the quality of their food, the portion sizes, the reasonable prices, and the unique atmosphere make this place a must-visit. Whether you're in the mood for great seafood or a delicious burger, Pawleys Island Tavern truly shines as one of the best dining spots in Pawleys Island.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in South Padre Island.

Frank's & Frank's Outback

Highlights
Great atmosphere
Extensive menu
Delicious food
Well made drinks
Best crab cake

As I stepped into Frank's & Frank's Outback, I was immediately greeted by a great atmosphere that perfectly blended a casual vibe with a touch of elegance. The rustic decor and cozy lighting created a comfortable and inviting ambiance that made me feel right at home.

The extensive menu offered a wide range of seafood options, catering to every palate. From fresh oysters to succulent shrimp, there was something for everyone. I was impressed by the variety of choices and the attention to detail in each dish.

Let's talk about the food. Oh, the food! It was nothing short of delightful. Every bite was bursting with flavor, showcasing the freshness and quality of the ingredients. The chefs at Frank's & Frank's Outback truly know how to prepare seafood to perfection.

And let me not forget to mention the well-made drinks. Their skilled bartenders crafted some of the best cocktails I've ever had. From classic martinis to innovative concoctions, each sip was a tantalizing experience that complemented the flavors of the seafood beautifully.

Now, let's get to the star of the show: the best crab cake. I have sampled many crab cakes in Pawleys Island, but Frank's & Frank's Outback surpassed them all. The crab cake was packed with generous chunks of sweet and tender crab meat, perfectly seasoned and cooked to a golden brown. It was a divine fusion of textures and flavors that left me craving for more.

In conclusion, Frank's & Frank's Outback exceeded my expectations with its great atmosphere, extensive menu, delicious food, well-made drinks, and of course, the best crab cake in town. If you're looking for a seafood dining experience that is nothing short of extraordinary, then this place is a must-visit.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Staten Island.

Quigley's Pint & Plate

Highlights
Favorite restaurant
Intimate atmosphere
Knowledgeable server
Delish oyster appetizer
Phenomenal dining experience

From the moment I stepped inside Quigley's Pint & Plate, I knew I had discovered something special. This cozy establishment quickly became my favorite restaurant in all of Pawleys Island. The intimate atmosphere and friendly staff immediately put me at ease.

My server was not only attentive, but also incredibly knowledgeable about the seafood options on the menu. She guided me through the selection, ensuring that I had the best dining experience possible.

Of course, the true highlight of the meal was the delicious oyster appetizer. The oysters were fresh and perfectly prepared, with a delicate balance of flavors that left me craving more. Each bite was a mouthwatering delight.

But it wasn't just the appetizer that impressed me. Every dish I tried at Quigley's Pint & Plate was a culinary masterpiece. From the perfectly seasoned shrimp to the flaky and moist fish, the seafood here surpassed all expectations.

The entire dining experience at Quigley's Pint & Plate was nothing short of phenomenal. The combination of excellent service, delightful ambiance, and extraordinary seafood made it an unforgettable meal. I can confidently say that Quigley's Pint & Plate is a must-visit for anyone looking for the best seafood in Pawleys Island.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Catalina Island.

Gios Italian Kitchen Pawleys Island

Gios Italian Kitchen Pawleys Island in Pawleys Island was a delightful surprise! While they may not specialize in seafood, their seafood pasta dish left me in a state of foodie bliss. The fresh shrimp and succulent scallops were perfectly cooked and paired perfectly with their homemade pasta. This hidden gem is not to be missed in the seafood scene of Pawleys Island!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in South Padre.

Chive Blossom Cafe

The Chive Blossom Cafe in Pawleys Island is a hidden seafood gem. Their dishes are creative and bursting with flavor. From the succulent crab cakes to the spicy shrimp and grits, every bite was a delight. The charming atmosphere and friendly staff made my dining experience even better. I definitely recommend visiting Chive Blossom Cafe for a seafood feast that will leave you wanting more!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Tybee Island.

Pawley's Raw Bar

I must say, Pawley's Raw Bar truly lives up to its name! The freshness of the seafood here is outstanding. From succulent oysters to flavorful shrimp, every bite was a seafood lover's dream. The lively atmosphere added a playful touch, making it a perfect spot for a casual and fun dining experience. Don't miss out on their delicious daily specials!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Sanibel Island.

Bistro 217

Bistro 217 in Pawleys Island is a seafood lover's paradise! The menu features an array of delicious seafood options that are sure to delight your taste buds. From the succulent lobster to the fresh and flavorful shrimp, every bite is like a taste of coastal heaven. This charming eatery combines excellent service, creative dishes, and a relaxed atmosphere for a truly memorable seafood dining experience. So, if you're seeking the best seafood in Pawleys Island, look no further than Bistro 217!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Mount Pleasant.

Pawley's Island Seafood

Pawley's Island Seafood in Pawleys Island is a hidden seafood paradise! The flavors in their dishes are bold and unforgettable, like a tangy tango on your taste buds. The freshness of the seafood is truly unbeatable. Don't leave without trying their famous grilled lobster, it will transport you to seafood nirvana. Prepare to be impressed!

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Rhode Island.

Rustic Table

Rustic Table in Pawleys Island is a hidden gem that seafood lovers must try. The innovative and artistically presented dishes, like their succulent lobster roll, will have your taste buds dancing with joy. The cozy yet chic ambiance adds to the overall delightful dining experience.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Howth Ireland.

Get Carried Away Southern Market and Catering

Get Carried Away Southern Market and Catering in Pawleys Island is a hidden gem for seafood lovers! Their fresh and flavorful seafood dishes will have you coming back for more. Don't miss out on their mouthwatering shrimp and grits or their succulent crab cakes. This charming market and catering service will definitely leave you carried away with delicious seafood delights.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Coronado Island.

J Peters Grill & Bar - Pawleys

J Peters Grill & Bar - Pawleys in Pawleys Island is a tantalizing seafood haven! From the moment I stepped foot in this delightful establishment, I knew I was in for a treat. The menu boasts an impressive array of oceanic delights that will make any seafood aficionado weak at the knees. The dishes are masterfully executed, each bite bursting with flavor that will transport your taste buds to the depths of the sea. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, ready to guide you through the culinary adventure that awaits. Don't miss their fresh catch of the day – it's a game-changer! Trust me, J Peters Grill & Bar - Pawleys is an absolute must-visit for seafood lovers venturing to Pawleys Island. It's an experience you won't soon forget!

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in South Florida.

Captain John's Seafood Grill

I must say, Captain John's Seafood Grill in Pawleys Island is a true catch! From the moment I entered, I was hooked by the inviting atmosphere and friendly staff. The menu was teeming with a multitude of tantalizing seafood options. From succulent shrimp to flaky fish, every bite burst with freshness and flavor. And let's not forget the star of the show - their famous crab cakes. These delectable delights were a true crowd-pleaser, with a delightful blend of sweet crabmeat and savory seasonings. The portions were generous, ensuring that even the heartiest of appetites would be satisfied. With its combination of top-notch service and extraordinary seafood, Captain John's Seafood Grill truly sails above the competition.

You might also want to check out the best seafood in South Lake Tahoe.